Hi there,

If you want to work at BCG do not reject this offer. Genuinely, it's truly running a great risk assuming you'll get an offer next year, let alone even get invited. You're always playing with odds when it comes to applications/interview.

You need to decide if the 30% pay cut now is worth the career bump/boost, learning, prestige, network, exposure, of BCG.

Personally? If it were me? I'd take it.

Again, personal choice, but your decision is: BCG or not BCG. Your decision is not: BCG nor or later

Hello,

Your situation presents a significant decision to make, and I can understand why it's challenging. Transitioning from a Business Consulting Associate role at a Big 4 firm to a Business Analyst position at BCG comes with its own set of considerations. Here are some factors to weigh:

Pros of Accepting the BCG Offer:

Long-Term Growth: BCG offers substantial growth potential. If you perform well, you can expect rapid advancement and significant increases in compensation.

Brand and Network: Joining BCG adds a prestigious brand to your resume and provides access to a global network that can be invaluable for your career.

Learning Opportunities: BCG offers a different work environment and approach compared to Big 4 firms. You'll likely gain exposure to a broader range of industries and challenges.

Cons of Accepting the BCG Offer:

Immediate Pay Cut: Accepting the Business Analyst role means taking a pay cut initially. This can be a significant adjustment, especially if you have financial commitments.

One-Year Delay: You mentioned that it may take about a year to get promoted at BCG. Consider the opportunity cost of this delay in terms of your career progression and earnings.

Financial Impact: A 30% pay cut can impact your lifestyle, savings, and financial goals. Evaluate how comfortable you are with this change.

Alternative Considerations:

Negotiation: While BCG mentioned that salary negotiation isn't possible in your region, it's still worth discussing your concerns with them. They may offer other incentives or benefits to help offset the pay cut.

Future Applications: If you decide not to accept the offer now, you can certainly apply to BCG again next year once you meet the Associate role's experience requirements. Keep building your skills and resume in the meantime.

Long-Term Goals: Consider your long-term career goals and whether the benefits of joining BCG align with those aspirations. Think about the impact of this move on your career trajectory.

Lifestyle Adjustment: Assess your readiness to adjust your lifestyle temporarily to accommodate the lower salary.

Ultimately, the decision depends on your personal and career priorities. If you value the long-term growth potential, brand, and learning opportunities that BCG offers, it may be worth accepting the Business Analyst role. However, if the immediate pay cut poses significant challenges or doesn't align with your financial goals, waiting and reapplying next year is a reasonable option.

It's advisable to have open discussions with BCG to fully understand the benefits, expectations, and potential for future promotions. Additionally, consult with financial advisors or mentors who can provide personalized guidance based on your financial situation and career aspirations.

Make your decision based on what you believe will best serve your career and personal growth in the long run. If you have further questions or need more advice, feel free to reach out.

Best regards, Frederic

Hey!

But I'm thinking if it might make sense to reject the offer from BCG now and just apply again next year once I'm eligible for the Associate role. 

DO NOT reject the BCG offer. If you do this, chances are, they won't let you reapply ever again. And if they allow it, it doesn't mean you will 100% manage to get an offer next time. There's always a chance to face an interviewer that doesn't like you or a case type you're not familiar with.

Seriously, if you don't have many responsibilities in life yet, just take the pay cut and consider it as payment for the extra experience you'll get at BCG compared to Big4.

When you are young, always choose experience over the monetary gains. You'll thank yourself later.

Good luck,
Nick

(editiert)

Hello there,

Thank you for providing a lot of details that allow us to better assess your situation from an outsider's perspective.

I would not risk rescinding the offer and reapplying next year as there is no guarantee that you will get a better offer next year.

If you don't have any major responsibilities in your life at the moment, you could consider taking the pay cut and hoping for a promotion within a year of joining BCG. But even then, there is no guarantee that you will be promoted within a year.  

If I were you, I would make a clear list of the pros and cons based on the trade-offs you have outlined.  You are about to make an important life decision and you will receive potentially conflicting opinions from family, friends, and even strangers from PrepLounge. Ultimately, you will have to make this decision for yourself and do what you think is the best.

Whatever decision you end up taking, I wish you the best of luck!

Kind regards

Margot

Hi there,

Congratulations on the offer! In terms of your question:

Q: I'm thinking if it might make sense to reject the offer from BCG now and just apply again next year once I'm eligible for the Associate role. 

I don’t see why you should do it if you are going to get the Associate role in one year within BCG. 

If you apply again, most likely you will do it in one year. So if you do so:

1. Best case scenario: you save 30% of your current salary
2. Worst case scenario: you don’t get into BCG and are stuck with the Big4

Even in the best-case scenario, you will have all the time and effort to apply and get an offer again.

For this reason, unless you are extermely risk-loving, I would recommend joining now.

Best,

Francesco

Here are a few thoughts and advice based on my experience:

Consider long-term career growth: BCG is a renowned consulting firm with excellent opportunities for professional development and advancement. Accepting the Business Analyst role could be a stepping stone towards the Associate role and beyond. Think about the long-term growth potential and the impact it could have on your career trajectory.

Evaluate the financial implications: While the initial pay cut may seem significant, it's important to consider the potential for future promotions and increased compensation at BCG. Double your current take-home pay, along with a sizable signing bonus, can be a substantial financial reward in the long run. Assess your financial situation and determine if you can manage the temporary adjustment in income.

Assess your readiness for the role: Reflect on your current skillset and experience. If you believe that the Business Analyst role at BCG will provide valuable learning opportunities and enhance your consulting capabilities, it may be worth considering. Evaluate how the role aligns with your professional goals and aspirations.

Explore alternative options: If the pay cut poses significant challenges or doesn't align with your financial goals at this stage of your career, waiting and reapplying for the Associate role next year is a reasonable option. Use this time to further develop your skills and gain additional experience that will make you a stronger candidate.

Ultimately, the decision depends on your personal priorities, risk tolerance, and long-term career goals. It's advisable to have open discussions with BCG to fully understand the benefits, expectations, and potential for future promotions

Take the offer, do well, get promoted, get the top box performance (Q1) and your bonus over the years will be significantly higher than your peers and what you'd be earning at Big 4. 

The overall benefits of shifting to BCG at a BA level far outweigh you staying at Big 4 (prestige, exit opportunities, growth, internal opportunities etc).

Lastly, in the mid-long term, one year difference really doesnt make a difference. 

Take the offer. Not only you may not get an offer next year… you will lose one year of fast paced learning experience.

To be very clear: even if it works as planned… you lose on the long run, because you will be missing on the learning experience provided by BCG.

Hi there,

To simplify your thought process I recommend you remove the short term money from the equation. 

Would you accept the BCG offer for the same money you’re getting today? If the answer is yes, why? 

This is what I would consider vs the short-term money drawback.

I hope this helps!

Alberto

Hi there!

Don't reject it. Or at least I wouldn't. 

You don't know what's going to happen in a year. And you don't know if you're going to get the offer again. Many things can get in the way. 

If you have it, just take it now and make the most of it. The added benefit will be that since you'll be in a more junior position than what you're capable of, you'll have a smoother integration process in the firm. 

Best,
Cristian

———————————————

Practicing for interviews? Check out my latest case based on a first-round MBB interview >>> SoyTechnologies