I am concerned that revealing my current situation with BCG might lead to the question, "If BCG also gives you an offer, which one will you choose?" In general, how should I answer the question, "Why didn't you get an offer from BCG?" in a way that avoids further related questions and doesn't make me seem like a weak performer who didn't succeed in getting an offer?
Werde aktiv in unserer Community aus über 457.000 Gleichgesinnten!
Recently, I was invited for a partner interview for a consulting intern position at KPMG. Last summer, I had a summer internship at BCG, and I will know their offer/reject decision after my final interview, which is expected in July/August. If the partner asks me, "Why didn't you get an offer after your internship at BCG?" what should I say to avoid both indicating that I am still waiting for an offer from BCG and appearing as an unsuccessful intern?
Übersicht der Antworten
-
Upvotes
-
Datum aufsteigend
-
Datum absteigend
Hi there,
Q: What should I say to avoid both indicating that I am still waiting for an offer from BCG and appearing as an unsuccessful intern?
I would say the truth and explain that you have a pending decision from BCG. The fact that you might have another offer will increase the perception you are a good fit for consulting.
If they ask you “If BCG also gives you an offer, which one will you choose?”, you can say you would be happy with both offers (assuming that's true). To make a decision, you would prefer to complete the process, have the opportunity to talk with people in both companies and have more details about the offers. Then you can add what you like about KPMG, using your answer for “Why KPMG”.
You can find an example below.
“I think both companies are great and can offer an interesting career in consulting. I believe my possible final decision will be based on how each company could help me to grow, as this is one of the most important elements for me. To have a complete picture, I think it would make sense to make a decision once completed the process, talked with people in both companies and have more details about the offers. I already know that KPMG is great for [SPECIFIC REASONS WHY YOU LIKE KPMG]. Based on that, if we have time, I would also like to ask you a couple of questions later about your experience at KPMG and how it allowed you to grow as a person and from a career point of view.”
Hope this helps,
Francesco
Hi there,
First of all, congratulations on the progress in the application process with KPMG thus far!
I would be happy to share my thoughts on your question:
- First of all, an internship is by no means a failure if you have not received a return offer. In many industries there are no return offers at all, and even in consulting it is not the standard to receive one.
- Moreover, when discussing your current situation, you could simply mention that you are in the process of considering various opportunities.
- Lastly, if you are pressed on which offer you would choose, I would advise you to express your focus on the current interview process with KPMG, showing your respect for the opportunity at hand and avoiding any speculation about future decisions.
If you would like a more detailed discussion on your specific situation, please don't hesitate to contact me directly.
Best,
Hagen
Hi there,
Whenever asked about “Why A instead of B?”, always play the personal experience and connection card.
Just highlight how you enjoyed your interactions with people from A more than with people from B. No one can argue with your experience. :-)
Cheers,
Florian
Since you actually have not received a decision from BCG yet - a good choice could be to just say that.
Though it can invite a potential counter-question of choosing between a KPMG offer vs BCG offer (hypothetical). That is one question you would definitely want to prepare for - with the right arguments that show a clear preference for KPMG (during the KPMG interview)
But you do want to say that you don't know the outcome yet! :)
Regarding “which one would you choose…”, honestly, just turn the table… if you have the option to choose, it's the Partner that should be answering that question, not you. I mean this in a diplomatic way. You had a good time, it's a great company. But you are enjoying your interview process and the people you know at KPMG. Whatever you do, don't say anything negative.
I would just be honest that you are still waiting to hear back on whether or not you're getting a full-time offer.
I don't see why you would hide that.
Best,
Cristian
Tell the truth and share you are still waiting for a decision. This can also help in a potential negotiation with KPMG if you get an offer from them.
Best,
Alberto
Verwandte Produkte
GYM Program - 5 Sessions von Francesco
- 100% FREE Coaching Until Offer
- Instantly Crack 90%+ Cases
- $1900+ in Bonus Materials
Verwandte Artikel
Karriereweg in der Beratung
BCG Case-Interview
Consulting Industrie Trends in 2023
Was ist Management Consulting?
MBB Zielhochschulen in den USA
PowerPoint für Berater
Arbeitszeiten im Consulting
M&A Consulting
Roland Berger Consulting Case Interviews
Leitfaden zu OC&C Consulting
Managementberatungen in Singapur
Beraterjargon
Consulting Recruitment
Work-Life-Balance in der Beratung – Alles, was du wissen musst
Coffee Chat Fragen in der Beratung
Consulting Survival Guide
Excel for Consultants
Die Vor- und Nachteile der Arbeit bei einer Top-Beratungsfirma
Wie man ein Consulting-Praktikum bekommt - Tipps und Tricks
Starte jetzt deine Karriere im Consulting
Consulting-Gehälter in Australien
Überwinde deine Schwächen mit ChatGPT für deine Consulting-Karriere
Was ist Sustainability Consulting?
Consulting Gehälter in Frankreich
Werde Top-Berater: Der Recruiting-Prozess für Consultants
Namhafte Tier 2 Consulting Firmen
Die Rolle von Diversität und Inklusion in der Beratung
Die interessantesten Consulting Firmen neben MBB
Was ist Automotive Consulting?
Consulting Gehälter in DACH 2024
Beratergehälter in Kanada
Was ist Change Management Consulting?
Typische Begriffe in Case-Interviews für Consulting Firmen
Was ist Leadership Consulting?
Remote Consulting: Die Veränderung im Arbeitsleben eines Beraters
Das Kündigungsschreiben im Consulting
Lohnt sich ein MBA oder MiM für die Beratungskarriere?
10 Gerüchte über Unternehmensberater
Restrukturierungsberatung - Was ist das?
16 Persönlichkeitstest
Verbessere deine Kommunikationsfähigkeiten
Bleiben Sie informiert und navigieren Sie sicher durch die Zukunft der
KI Systeme im Consulting
Intelligente Lösungen für eine nachhaltige Zukunft: KI im Consulting
Was sind Decision-Making-Frameworks und warum sind sie wichtig?
Consulting-Gehälter in den USA 2024
Top-Beratungen in den USA – Die besten Arbeitgeber 2024
Bist du bereit für die nächste Ära der Consulting?
Top-Beratungen in Deutschland – Die besten Arbeitgeber 2024
Was ist der Unterschied zwischen Sustainability Consulting und ESG?
Was ist Public Sector Consulting?
Was ist Healthcare Consulting?
Verwandte Cases
Verwandte Case-Interview-Basics-Artikel
Die Rolle der Hypothese im Consulting
Entdecke, wie Hypothesen in der dynamischen Welt der Beratung als Leitfaden dienen und zu innovativen Lösungen und transformativen Ergebnissen führen.
Die PESTEL-Analyse für die Beratung
Nutze das Potenzial der PESTEL-Analyse, um in der dynamischen Welt der Beratung erfolgreich zu sein.
Das Capability Maturity Model (CMM)
Entdecke das CMM Framework sowie Capability Maturity Model Integration und nutze sie zur Verbesserung von Prozessen in deiner Organisation!