Hi guys,
Basically i couldn't find a story that fit the question he asked me. a mistake from my part didn't prepare well enough lesson learned. so he skipped the whole PEI
the case part was after PEI so i got a bit nervous i tried my best not show it, he started saying the prompt he was fast and mck prompt usually include too much info so that's not helping with him being fast and also he was using laptop mic so his voice 30% of the times was cut so i had to re-ask him a lot of info which made him a bit annoyed and passive aggressive but he was nice enough because he obviously was trying to not show it but i could see it closely. so we got to the second part of the question and i basically made 3 math mistakes due to all this anxiety building up from everything and he basically stopped me at the second question and finished the case.
so i know this interview is a shit-show and i won't pass it no matter what, but my question is I have a second interview with APartner after two days, do you think that if I did well on case and fit part it'll make them give me a second chance or it's a done deal? and if so should i even take it or not at this point?
i have interviewed with other companies i got offer from T2 and final rounds and T2 and another MBB so i think my casing skills aren't bad but it's specifically the anxiety after messing the PEI part that made me fail the case.
bombed case & PEI first round Mck interview


Hi there,
Sorry to hear that it went down like this. These things happen, which is why it makes sense to apply to multiple firms and not just one.
Based on your description, I would be surprised if you pass to the second round even with a very good performance in the second interview. Perhaps, there is a slight chance that you do so well on the second one that they assume you had an issue in the first one and they progress you further.
Still, regardless of this, you should do the interview. It's a great learning experience in and of itself and you don't get many opportunities like these in life. At the end of the day, it's only one hour from your life, but what you get out of it is worth a lot more.
Best of luck on the second one!
Cristian

Even though you may feel like you didn't do very well, there is normally a gap between your perception of your performance and your interviewers view of your performance.
Go into the second interview relaxed. What is done is done and you need to focus on doing well in the second.
Take this as a great learning experience in your journey. Your next step is to work on trying to fight that anxiousness feeling hindering your performance. It will help you in the future on consulting engagements in front of clients.

Hi there,
This is indeed an interesting question which is probably relevant for a lot of users, thus I am happy to provide my perspective on it:
- First of all, it's important to remember that interviews can be stressful and unpredictable, and it's not uncommon for things to go wrong or for candidates to make mistakes. While it's frustrating and disappointing to have a less-than-ideal interview, it's important to try to learn from the experience and move forward.
- In terms of whether you should continue with the second interview, it ultimately depends on your own goals and priorities. If you are still interested in McKinsey and believe that you have the potential to succeed in the role, then it may be worth attending the second interview and using it as an opportunity to showcase your skills and fit. You can also use the second interview to address any concerns or misunderstandings that may have come up during the first interview, and to demonstrate your commitment and enthusiasm for the firm.
- On the other hand, if you are not sure whether McKinsey is the right fit for you, or if you are feeling discouraged or unsure about your chances of success, then it may be best to withdraw from the process and focus on the other opportunities that you have.
In case you want a more detailed discussion on what to do in your specific situation, please feel free to contact me directly.
Best,
Hagen

Hi,
sorry to hear about this experience. That certainly is not pleasant.
You cannot change the past but you can influence the future. You should definitely take the second interview. You are not a quitter.
Try your best to impress the interviewer in your second interview. You've already got an offer under your belt and you have still some final rounds coming up. This should ease your mind that whatever happens in this particular recruiting round does not derail your career planning. At the very least, use it as a practice arena to deal with your anxiety. That should definitely be useful for your remaining interviews.
Best of luck

Hi there,
To be fully honest, this does not sound like the best starting position.
Yes, there are two interviews but in theory, you need to impress both interviewers and throughout the whole process all interviewers consistently.
Still, it is not the end of the line:
- My experience is that interviewees often see their performance much more negatively than how the interviewer perceives it
- If you show an exceptional performance during the second interview, the second interview will have a strong case for giving you another shot
Make sure that you go into the next interview confidently, hold your head up high, and do not let your initial performance derail the second.
Have a look at the articles that also help you elevate your performance.
https://www.preplounge.com/mckinsey-pei
https://www.preplounge.com/en/articles/mckinsey-interview
All the best,
Florian
Cheers,
Florian

Hi there,
Sorry to hear about the issues with the first interview. In terms of your questions:
1) Do you think that if I did well on case and fit part it'll make them give me a second chance or it's a done deal?
Both interviewers should agree that you should move forward in order to move to the second round. If they have doubts, at McKinsey you may be offered an extra first-round interview.
2) And if so should I even take it or not at this point?
Definitely take the interview as you have nothing to lose at this point. Worst case, it will be a way to practice for your coming final rounds.
Good luck!
Francesco

Hi there,
Sorry to hear and glad you're taking it positively with an important lesson learnt. As for the following interview, I'm a bit puzzled as to why you have a Partner interview following a first round interview.
In any case, this sounds quite bad to be blunt and I never heard an interviewer skipping the entire PEI section. Considering the number of high quality applicants in McKinsey's pipeline, they are likely to move on to the next candidate.
That being said, if the interview is still on I'd personally attend anyways to see what happens. You have nothing to loose but some more experience to gain.
All the best and keep it up!
Moritz

Always give your best, no matter what.
You probably still have a shot. Shoot it.
Here's some reading to help
https://www.preplounge.com/en/articles/pitfalls-case-interview-preparation
https://www.preplounge.com/en/articles/how-to-shift-your-mindset-to-ace-the-case
https://www.preplounge.com/en/articles/tell-me-about-yourself-interview-question

Hello,
Sorry to hear about this situation. Indeed, succeeding at interviews requires a lot of hard work and a little bit of luck.
Here are my thoughts:
1) In the best case that your 2nd interview goes absolute flawlessly, then they may for ask for a 3rd interview since there is a tie between a No and a Yes
2) In case there are some errors in the 2nd interview and it goes average, then it seems like you will be rejected
3) In the mean time, do the best you can to work on the things that you can control! Work on PEI, use the right set of headphones/speakers so you can hear very well, practice doing math under pressure, etc!
All the best!
Rushabh

There's a reason why they do 2 interviews. If you do well enough you might be able to progress to second round. Of course, it has to be a really good performance…









