What to do after R2 rejection

Question

I made it to R2 for McK FT BA this past summer but didn't get the offer. I'm a grad student and I've had to take some time off for personal/health reasons and therefore my graduation date/thesis defense is getting pushed back a semester to Dec 2026. Can/should I re-apply for the FT BA role next cycle? How do MBB firms/offices view re-applicants who have interviewed with them before?

I'm interested in trying again but I'm wondering if the fact that I've interviewed previously will hurt my chances?

Answer 1

Hi there,

You can absolutely reapply — and doing so after a Round 2 interview actually strengthens your profile, not weakens it. MBB firms, including McKinsey, don’t hold past rejections against you, especially if there’s been meaningful time and development since your last interview.

Here’s how to approach it:

Wait at least one full recruiting cycle (usually 12 months) before reapplying. Since your graduation is now later, that fits perfectly.
On your new application, subtly emphasize what’s changed — new coursework, leadership roles, internships, or personal growth from your time off.
Don’t overexplain the prior rejection; firms keep detailed notes and know strong candidates sometimes just need another shot.
When reinterviewing, expect a higher bar — they’ll want to see sharper structure, stronger communication, and self-awareness from last time.

Re-applicants who show progress and reflection are often very well received. In fact, many successful consultants didn’t make it on their first try.

Happy to help you prep – feel free to reach out.

Best,
Evelina

Answer 2

Hi there,

You can definitely try again, but keep in mind that McKinsey has a one-year ban for re-applying to the same role after an unsuccessful interview. Other MBB firms have similar policies, though timelines can vary by office and role. Since your graduation and thesis defense are now in Dec 2026, you’ll want to plan your next application so it aligns with their eligibility rules.

Answer 3

If you've failed before, it doesn't affect your chances at all.

If anything, it helps. Because now you have clear expectations of what will come and hopefully targeted feedback that you can work on.

Make sure you also apply broadly to distribute your risk across multiple applications.

You might find this guide useful:

Expert Guide: Build A Winning Application Strategy

Best,
Cristian

Answer 4

They know that life happens.

In any case, how would an answer change what you do? Even if they would have doubts, you should still apply...

Answer 5

Sorry to hear that you're battling some challenges, I hope that those clear up.

With regards to re-application, always be sure to know what the black out period is before re-applying (many companies it is 1-2 years) and can depend on your office location.

If you're in the clear on the ban, the key in re-application strategy is ensuring that you can tell the story of how you're a stronger applicant this time (through CV and cover letter) and show it through your casing and fit interviews.

Good luck!

Answer 6

Hey there :)

you can definitely reapply. MBB actually sees re-applicants positively if you show clear improvement or new experiences since your last cycle. Just focus on what’s changed for you, skills, projects, or achievements, and be ready to explain any gaps honestly. Your previous interview won’t hurt as long as you come back stronger and more prepared.

best,
Alessa :)