PrepLounge - link to homepage PrepLounge - link to homepage
Consulting Consulting
Consulting Finance General
Login Sign up for free Sign up for free
Consulting Finance General
Community
Meeting Board
Consulting Q&A
Interview Partner
Premium Membership
Coaching
Coaches
Coaching Packages
Consulting Q&A
Resources
Case Interview Basics
Case Library
AI Casebot
Tests & Guides
Mental Math Tool
Stress Questions
Drills
Video Tutorials
Brainteaser
Career
Employers
Career Events
Consulting Jobs
Consulting Blog
Sign up for free
Login
Community
Meeting Board
Consulting Q&A
Interview Partner
Premium Membership
Coaching
Coaches
Coaching Packages
Consulting Q&A
Resources
Case Interview Basics
Case Library
AI Casebot
Tests & Guides
Mental Math Tool
Stress Questions
Drills
Video Tutorials
Brainteaser
Career
Employers
Career Events
Consulting Jobs
Consulting Blog
Schedule mock interviews on the Meeting Board, join the latest community discussions in our Consulting Q&A and find like-minded Interview Partners to connect and practice with!
Meeting Board
Consulting Q&A
Interview Partner
Premium Membership
Back to overview
Anonymous A
on Mar 31, 2025
Global
I want to receive updates regarding this question via email.

SUPER confused on this one Math Question, help please !

Question context (summarized for simplicity) 

Trucking: 10% of Total Cost. 5% of trucking cost is FC and the other 95% is VC. VC is reducing by half

Refining: 30% of Total Cost. Refining cost is being reduced by 50%, but price will also increase by 25%

What is the cost savings from both initiatives?

Calculation from Casebook:

Variable trucking costs, which represent 95% of the total cost structure, will decrease by 50%, leading to an overall costs savings of 95% x 50% = 47.5%.

Refining costs drop by half because only half as many sugar beets are being refined. However, then there is a 25% increase in costs per beet. So the costs go from “X” to “.5X” to “.625X”, an overall savings of 37.5%.

My confusion

Why is it that for trucking costs, you are finding the cost savings directly after taking 95% x 50%. But for refining, you need to take 1-0.625 to get the answer?

I've been asking ChatGPT about this, and the points don't seem to make much sense (e.g. it's cause refining has sequential percentages multiplying).

Could someone please help me understand the underlying concept? I want to know when must I do '1-' vs just taking the percentage immediately, not only for this question but in general

Thank you !

4
700+
17
Write an answer
Be the first to answer!
Nobody has responded to this question yet.
Top answer
Michelle
on Mar 31, 2025

For the trucking cost you only have a reduction in cost that equals to 50% of the 95% so you can calculate the savings simply by multiplying 95% by 50%

If you only had a cost reduction for the refining cost you would be able to calculate this the same way but since you also have an increase in price you will have to add that to the remaining cost, before you can calculate the savings.

1.  Calculate the reduction in cost by 50% (1*0.5)

2. Add the price increase, which gives you the new cost (0.5*1.25 = 0.625)

3. Calculate the difference between old and new cost (1-0.625 = 0.375)

Hope this helps :)

15
0 comments
Alessa
Coach
on Apr 02, 2025
xMcKinsey & Company | xBCG | xRB | >400 coachings | feel free to schedule an intro call for free

Hey ?

Totally valid confusion—and you're actually very close to getting it. Here’s the clear rule you can use to understand when to subtract from 1 vs when to take a direct product:

✅ Rule of thumb:

? If the question is asking for cost savings as a percentage of the original, then:

  • You always want to end up comparing the new cost to the original cost
  • So if the cost goes from X → Y, then cost savings = (X - Y) / X = 1 - (Y / X)

Let’s now look at your examples:

? Trucking:

Trucking is 10% of Total Cost, and within that:

  • 5% is Fixed → unaffected
  • 95% is Variable → reduced by 50%

So within Trucking, your new cost is: 0.05 + 0.95 * 0.5 = 0.05 + 0.475 = 0.525

That means total Trucking cost is now 52.5% of what it was before, or a 47.5% reduction → and that’s what they wrote.

? They wrote 95% x 50% = 47.5% savings, which skips a step but is mathematically the same because only 95% of cost is affected.

? Refining:

You start with cost = X

Step 1: You’re refining half the sugar beets → cost becomes 0.5X

Step 2: But now the per-unit cost increases by 25% → cost becomes: 0.5X * 1.25 = 0.625X

So now the cost is 62.5% of original → savings = 1 - 0.625 = 0.375 = 37.5%

? Here, the changes are sequential multipliers that act on the total cost, so you must calculate the end result, then subtract to get the savings.

? So when to subtract from 1?

Whenever you're calculating "savings", or "reduction" as a percentage of the original—you’ll always want to do:

Savings % = 1 - (new cost / original cost)

The trucking shortcut only works cleanly if you’re applying a single % cut to a part of the cost.

Let me know if you'd like to go through more examples or build an easy cheat sheet for these types of questions ?

Best,
Alessa ?

13
Contact coach
0 comments
Deleted user
on Apr 03, 2025

 

When do we do “1 – …” vs. just take the percentage?

In both situations, the underlying concept is:

Savings % = 1 - (Fraction Remaining)

  • If you have the fraction (or percent) that remains (like 0.625 → 62.5%), you do 1 - 0.625 = 0.375 (37.5% savings).
  • If, on the other hand, you already computed how much is saved (like 0.95 * 0.50 = 0.475 → 47.5% saved), then you’re already at the final “savings fraction” and don’t need to do “1 – …”.

So it’s not that “one scenario must do it, and the other must not.” It’s just a different presentation style:

  • Trucking: The write-up jumped straight to the fraction saved: 95% * 50% = 47.5%.
  • Refining: The write-up jumped straight to the fraction remaining (0.625) and then subtracted from 1 to get 37.5%.

Either approach works; they’re just different ways of doing the fraction arithmetic. Whenever you see “we have a new fraction of the original left,” you do 1 - (that fraction) to see how much was removed/saved. Whenever you see “we are cutting X% out of a portion,” that already is the portion saved.

12
0 comments
Pedro
Coach
on Mar 31, 2025
Bain | EY-Parthenon | Former Principal | 1.5h session | 30% discount 1st session

Trucking cost savings: 

Initial Cost: 95% + 5% = 100%

Final Cost: 95% * 50% + 5% = 52.5%

Savings = Initial Cost - Final Cost = 100% - 52.5% = 47.5%


Refining cost savings: 

Initial Cost: 100%

Final Cost: 100% * (1 + 25%) * 50% = 62.5%

Savings = Initial Cost - Final Cost = 100% - 62.5% = 37.5%

 

So what's different vs. your casebook? In the truck savings it calculated the savings directly. In the refining savings it calculated the new cost (not the savings), so you need to do an additional calculation to get the savings. 

11
Contact coach
0 comments
Similar Questions
Consulting
To the Professional Coaches: Your experience with students that are bad in math
on Oct 10, 2024
Global
6
1.1k
55
6 Answers
1.1k Views
Consulting
I can not catch up with what the interviewer is saying
on Oct 19, 2024
Global
8
1.4k
72
8 Answers
1.4k Views
Consulting
What are the maths topics needed to ace the Redrock Study in the Mckinsey Solve Game?
on Nov 10, 2024
Global
3
1.1k
30
3 Answers
1.1k Views
Consulting
Question about
Case
the number of bottles shouldn't be 530 in Year 5?
on Nov 27, 2024
Global
1
600+
18
1 Answer
600+ Views
Consulting
How do I Case Prep while interning at an MBB?
on Dec 01, 2024
Global
5
1.0k
47
5 Answers
1.0k Views
Consulting
Tough Math Casebook to Prep
on Jan 13, 2025
Global
6
800+
15
6 Answers
800+ Views
Consulting
Could someone give a good explanation of ROI>100% using the ROI=NET PROFIT/ COST OF INVESTMENT?
on Jan 30, 2025
Global
4
1.3k
22
4 Answers
1.3k Views
Consulting
Question about
Case
Calculation question - data sources
on Feb 06, 2025
Global
4
800+
19
4 Answers
800+ Views
Consulting
Question about
Case
Annual maintenance costs in 4.4
on Feb 09, 2025
Global
5
800+
21
5 Answers
800+ Views
Consulting
Hi, I am confused about what exactly is the formula for ROI. Is it (Profit-Cost)/Cost (see picture 1) or Profit/Cost (see picture 2)? Both cases are from Darden and googling online both equations show up. Thank you a lot!
on Feb 18, 2025
Global
4
900+
22
4 Answers
900+ Views
Consulting
EY-P RecruitingTest
on Feb 18, 2025
Global
6
900+
16
6 Answers
900+ Views
Consulting
Any tips to project yourself as organised and strutured as possible in the stressful environment of a case interview?
on Mar 17, 2025
Global
9
800+
25
9 Answers
800+ Views
Consulting
Why do I never feel ready for an MBB interview ?
on Apr 13, 2025
Global
17
1.0k
27
17 Answers
1.0k Views
Consulting
MBB math questions resources
on Apr 14, 2025
Global
11
700+
26
11 Answers
700+ Views
Consulting
Why am I pretty great at Maths in Cases, but terrible at GMAT questions?
on Apr 15, 2025
Global
10
700+
22
10 Answers
700+ Views
Consulting
Is more Math Drills the way to solve my issue?
on Apr 27, 2025
Global
7
600+
15
7 Answers
600+ Views
Consulting
Why do I always black out when it comes to structuring my math approach in a case?
on Jul 01, 2025
Global
7
300+
15
7 Answers
300+ Views
Consulting
When to use Absolute vs % Comparisons?
on Jul 05, 2025
Global
4
100+
7
4 Answers
100+ Views
Consulting
I can't wrap my head around this one Math question for months...
on Jul 10, 2025
Global
4
100+
7
4 Answers
100+ Views
Consulting
Mental Maths: Best way to do division?
on Jul 20, 2025
Global
2
< 100
1
2 Answers
< 100 Views
Show more
Related Article
ROI and ROAS
When preparing for case interviews, ROI and ROAS are two concepts you'll encounter repeatedly. Both are key metrics that enable you to evaluate a company's success and measure the efficiency of investments.🔎 In this article, you’ll learn how to correctly apply ROI and ROAS in your case analyses and how to structure your answers clearly. What is ROI, And Why is it Important For Case Interviews?Return on Investment (ROI) measures how much profit a company generates relative to its investments. This metric helps you assess whether an investment was worthwhile. In a case interview, ROI is particularly useful for evaluating the efficiency of a proposed strategy or project.💡 Pro tip: A positive ROI means the company is earning more than it has invested, indicating a profit. A negative ROI points to losses.How to calculate ROI:Example: If a company invests €100,000 and earns €120,000, the ROI is 20%. This means the company has achieved a 20% profit on its investment. 
View article
Related Case
Expert case by
Francesco
MBB Final Round Case - Smart Education
4.6
33.3k times solved
Advanced
Interviewer-led
Open case
Similar Questions
Consulting
To the Professional Coaches: Your experience with students that are bad in math
on Oct 10, 2024
55
6
1.1k
Consulting
I can not catch up with what the interviewer is saying
on Oct 19, 2024
72
8
1.4k
Consulting
What are the maths topics needed to ace the Redrock Study in the Mckinsey Solve Game?
on Nov 10, 2024
30
3
1.1k
Consulting
Question about
Case
the number of bottles shouldn't be 530 in Year 5?
on Nov 27, 2024
18
1
600+
Consulting
How do I Case Prep while interning at an MBB?
on Dec 01, 2024
47
5
1.0k
Consulting
Tough Math Casebook to Prep
on Jan 13, 2025
15
6
800+
Consulting
Could someone give a good explanation of ROI>100% using the ROI=NET PROFIT/ COST OF INVESTMENT?
on Jan 30, 2025
22
4
1.3k
Consulting
Question about
Case
Calculation question - data sources
on Feb 06, 2025
19
4
800+
Consulting
Question about
Case
Annual maintenance costs in 4.4
on Feb 09, 2025
21
5
800+
Consulting
Hi, I am confused about what exactly is the formula for ROI. Is it (Profit-Cost)/Cost (see picture 1) or Profit/Cost (see picture 2)? Both cases are from Darden and googling online both equations show up. Thank you a lot!
on Feb 18, 2025
22
4
900+
Consulting
EY-P RecruitingTest
on Feb 18, 2025
16
6
900+
Consulting
Any tips to project yourself as organised and strutured as possible in the stressful environment of a case interview?
on Mar 17, 2025
25
9
800+
Consulting
Why do I never feel ready for an MBB interview ?
on Apr 13, 2025
27
17
1.0k
Consulting
MBB math questions resources
on Apr 14, 2025
26
11
700+
Consulting
Why am I pretty great at Maths in Cases, but terrible at GMAT questions?
on Apr 15, 2025
22
10
700+
Consulting
Is more Math Drills the way to solve my issue?
on Apr 27, 2025
15
7
600+
Consulting
Why do I always black out when it comes to structuring my math approach in a case?
on Jul 01, 2025
15
7
300+
Consulting
When to use Absolute vs % Comparisons?
on Jul 05, 2025
7
4
100+
Consulting
I can't wrap my head around this one Math question for months...
on Jul 10, 2025
7
4
100+
Consulting
Mental Maths: Best way to do division?
on Jul 20, 2025
1
2
< 100
Show more
Questions by Categories
Questions about MBB
CV Questions
Personal Fit Questions
Everything for Your Career
  • Interview Coaching
  • Q&A
  • Interview Partner
  • Mental Math Tool
  • Interview Drills
  • Stress Questions
  • Blog
Everything for Your Career
  • Interview Coaching
  • Q&A
  • Interview Partner
  • Mental Math Tool
  • Interview Drills
  • Stress Questions
  • Blog
Popular in Consulting
  • Case Library
  • Meeting Board
  • Interview Partner
  • Case Interview Basics
  • Case Interview
  • Consulting Q&A
Popular in Finance
  • Finance Q&A
  • Interview in Investment Banking
  • Investment Banking Salaries
Popular in Consulting
  • Case Library
  • Meeting Board
  • Interview Partner
  • Case Interview Basics
  • Case Interview
  • Consulting Q&A
Popular in Finance
  • Finance Q&A
  • Interview in Investment Banking
  • Investment Banking Salaries
Consulting and Finance Employers
  • RWE Consulting
  • Whiteshield Advisory
  • All Employers »
About PrepLounge
  • For Companies
  • For Universities
  • For Coaches
  • About Us
  • Career
  • FAQ
© 2012 PrepLounge
Our servers are powered by electricity from renewable sources.
  • Cookies & Privacy
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Imprint
  • Sitemap
  • Contact
Facebook Linkedin Instagram TikTok Youtube
Questions or Feedback?
Select category
  • Select category
  • General Feedback
  • Case Interview Preparation
  • Coaching
  • Technical Problems
  • Other
Your name
Your email address
Cancel