PrepLounge - link to homepage PrepLounge - link to homepage
Consulting Consulting
Consulting Finance General
Login Sign up for free Sign up for free
Consulting Finance General
Community
Meeting Board
Consulting Q&A
Interview Partner
Premium Membership
Coaching
Coaches
Coaching Packages
Consulting Q&A
Resources
Case Interview Basics
Case Library
AI Casebot
Tests & Guides
Mental Math Tool
Stress Questions
Drills
Video Tutorials
Brainteaser
Career
Employers
Career Events
Consulting Jobs
Consulting Blog
Sign up for free
Login
Community
Meeting Board
Consulting Q&A
Interview Partner
Premium Membership
Coaching
Coaches
Coaching Packages
Consulting Q&A
Resources
Case Interview Basics
Case Library
AI Casebot
Tests & Guides
Mental Math Tool
Stress Questions
Drills
Video Tutorials
Brainteaser
Career
Employers
Career Events
Consulting Jobs
Consulting Blog
Schedule mock interviews on the Meeting Board, join the latest community discussions in our Consulting Q&A and find like-minded Interview Partners to connect and practice with!
Meeting Board
Consulting Q&A
Interview Partner
Premium Membership
Back to overview
Anonymous A
on Aug 12, 2023
Global
I want to receive updates regarding this question via email.

Is it better to keep the case structure light, or condensed?

I'm currently using 2 different learning materials: Case Coach and Crafting Cases. One difficulty I have is that the case structuring styles of these 2 materials are very different. Using these case examples, could you share your thoughts please?

1) Case Coach: the structure seems very fluid. Though simplified, I can spend more time talking through my views and hypotheses. However, the downside is that the structure seems a bit too “generic” and too “light”. I feel that if the interviewer probe deeper there's a possibility I could get lost.

2) Crafting Cases: 

Tend to go very deep and specific. Seems to be a good resource to practice structuring on my own, but I'm not sure whether it's the best structure for live interviews. Firstly, it's hard to come up with such a complicated structure in 1.5-2 min. Secondly, in real interviews it's hard to communicate the structure in 2 min; interviewers might think that I'm not “prioritizing” major issues for the case.

Note:

the pictures shown above are all publicly available information.

4
1.1k
16
Write an answer
Be the first to answer!
Nobody has responded to this question yet.
Top answer
Deleted user
on Aug 13, 2023

Hello,

I like the Crafting Cases approach more. You might not be able to come up with something this extensive on the fly, but this is the level of detail you want to be getting down to in your frameworks, and a good amount of specificity in the questions. So, you’d target a structure like this, and if you come up with 80% of the questions they have there, you should be good. Regarding communicating this to the interviewer, you should figure out a good structure that communicates the points succinctly over time with practice. I agree with your assessment that the Case Coach framework is both a bit too generic and not detailed enough.

9
0 comments
Ian
Coach
edited on Aug 12, 2023
Top US BCG / MBB Coach - 5,000 sessions |Tech, Platinion, Big 4 | 9/9 personal interviews passed | 95% candidate success

Hi there,

I much prefer crafting cases approach.

In fact, when my candidates work through all of my course, and want more frameworking practice, I point them to crafting cases.

They take the approach of truly solving the problem. Breaking it down in an objective-driven way that is logical. They focus on the why/how not just the what.

This is my personally pilosophy as well for coaching.

Case coach is a bit more rigid/generic/memorized.

Here's a bit more reading on that thinking (and how to prep properly):

https://www.preplounge.com/en/articles/how-to-shift-your-mindset-to-ace-the-case

https://www.preplounge.com/en/articles/candidate-led-cases-what-to-expect-and-example-cases

https://www.preplounge.com/en/articles/pitfalls-case-interview-preparation

8
Contact coach
0 comments
Pedro
Coach
on Aug 21, 2023
Bain | EY-Parthenon | Former Principal | 1.5h session | 30% discount 1st session

I prefer case coach - because I really don't like the “bucket” approach of that Crafting Cases example.

In a good framework, you are trying to answer a question in each specific step. “Customers is not really a question”… it is just a laundry list of good questions grouped into logical topics. Moreover, it uses the overused CCCP approach

In this sense, Case Coach is the right approach (that is actually a framework, and you could keep breaking each step into another 2-3 logical components. 

However, it misses something that is critical for a good case performance, i.e., it does not provide you any insights on what are the specific questions to ask. Crafting cases does not have a framework, but actually gives you insight on the specific questions to ask.

8
Contact coach
0 comments
Cristian
Coach
on Aug 18, 2023
#1 Rated McKinsey Coach | Top MBB Coach | Verifiable success rates

Hi there, 

If you have to choose, go for depth and breadth. 

Especially for firms such as McKinsey. 

So I'd lean more for the condensed version. 

Sharing with you an additional resource you might find useful:

  • Free Guide: Mastering Structuring & Brainstorming


Best,
Cristian

6
Contact coach
0 comments
Sign up for free to read all answers.
Sign up for free to read all answers.
Yes, I would like to be informed about new content, exciting jobs, relevant events, and selected employers.
By creating an account, I confirm that I agree to PrepLounge's Terms of Use. Please read our Privacy Policy.
Sign up with
You already have an account? Log in here.
Similar Questions
Consulting
The exhibits of the case
on Dec 28, 2024
Global
5
1.1k
24
5 Answers
1.1k Views
Consulting
What are some good recommendations for case books that focus on McKinsey-type cases?
on Jan 06, 2025
Asia
7
2.2k
22
7 Answers
2.2k Views
Consulting
Does anyone have advice on how to improve the brainstorming part?
on Jan 21, 2025
Global
7
900+
21
7 Answers
900+ Views
Consulting
Knowing what information to ask for
on Jan 24, 2025
Global
5
800+
21
5 Answers
800+ Views
Consulting
McKinsey PEI - What should I cover in the "Action" portion of my STAR Story?
on Jan 24, 2025
USA
6
1.0k
21
6 Answers
1.0k Views
Consulting
Case Structure
on Feb 05, 2025
DACH
6
700+
15
6 Answers
700+ Views
Consulting
Round 1 and two interviews and casing
on Mar 31, 2025
USA
10
700+
24
10 Answers
700+ Views
Consulting
How to structure this case?
on Mar 31, 2025
Europe
5
600+
21
5 Answers
600+ Views
Consulting
Fluctuations in casing performance - is this normal?
on Apr 06, 2025
Global
6
700+
20
6 Answers
700+ Views
Consulting
Follow-up questions and structuring
on Apr 17, 2025
Europe
10
800+
25
10 Answers
800+ Views
Consulting
How to Practice Structure Drills and Present in a Clear, Structured Way?
on Apr 19, 2025
Global
4
600+
17
4 Answers
600+ Views
Consulting
How strictly should I commit to being objective orientated?
on Apr 21, 2025
Global
7
700+
18
7 Answers
700+ Views
Consulting
Is more Math Drills the way to solve my issue?
on Apr 27, 2025
Global
7
600+
15
7 Answers
600+ Views
Consulting
McKinsey First Interview Question – Was My Approach Wrong?
on May 29, 2025
Global
6
400+
14
6 Answers
400+ Views
Consulting
Market Size the number of Pilots in your home country ?
on Jun 10, 2025
Global
4
200+
8
4 Answers
200+ Views
Consulting
Summarize before final recommendation?
on Jun 10, 2025
USA
7
300+
8
7 Answers
300+ Views
Consulting
MBB Interview – Differences & Structure Timing Advice?
on Jun 28, 2025
DACH
8
200+
7
8 Answers
200+ Views
Consulting
Exhibit Reading Approach
on Jul 15, 2025
Global
9
100+
5
9 Answers
100+ Views
Show more
Related Article
Case Interview Frameworks – Most Common Frameworks
Free case interview frameworks to boost your structure and stand out in interviews.
View article
Related Case
Expert case by
Francesco
BCG Case Style - Online Groceries [NEW]
5.0
10.1k times solved
Intermediate
Candidate-led
Open case
Similar Questions
Consulting
The exhibits of the case
on Dec 28, 2024
24
5
1.1k
Consulting
What are some good recommendations for case books that focus on McKinsey-type cases?
on Jan 06, 2025
22
7
2.2k
Consulting
Does anyone have advice on how to improve the brainstorming part?
on Jan 21, 2025
21
7
900+
Consulting
Knowing what information to ask for
on Jan 24, 2025
21
5
800+
Consulting
McKinsey PEI - What should I cover in the "Action" portion of my STAR Story?
on Jan 24, 2025
21
6
1.0k
Consulting
Case Structure
on Feb 05, 2025
15
6
700+
Consulting
Round 1 and two interviews and casing
on Mar 31, 2025
24
10
700+
Consulting
How to structure this case?
on Mar 31, 2025
21
5
600+
Consulting
Fluctuations in casing performance - is this normal?
on Apr 06, 2025
20
6
700+
Consulting
Follow-up questions and structuring
on Apr 17, 2025
25
10
800+
Consulting
How to Practice Structure Drills and Present in a Clear, Structured Way?
on Apr 19, 2025
17
4
600+
Consulting
How strictly should I commit to being objective orientated?
on Apr 21, 2025
18
7
700+
Consulting
Is more Math Drills the way to solve my issue?
on Apr 27, 2025
15
7
600+
Consulting
McKinsey First Interview Question – Was My Approach Wrong?
on May 29, 2025
14
6
400+
Consulting
Market Size the number of Pilots in your home country ?
on Jun 10, 2025
8
4
200+
Consulting
Summarize before final recommendation?
on Jun 10, 2025
8
7
300+
Consulting
MBB Interview – Differences & Structure Timing Advice?
on Jun 28, 2025
7
8
200+
Consulting
Exhibit Reading Approach
on Jul 15, 2025
5
9
100+
Show more
Questions by Categories
Questions about MBB
CV Questions
Personal Fit Questions
Everything for Your Career
  • Interview Coaching
  • Q&A
  • Interview Partner
  • Mental Math Tool
  • Interview Drills
  • Stress Questions
  • Blog
Everything for Your Career
  • Interview Coaching
  • Q&A
  • Interview Partner
  • Mental Math Tool
  • Interview Drills
  • Stress Questions
  • Blog
Popular in Consulting
  • Case Library
  • Meeting Board
  • Interview Partner
  • Case Interview Basics
  • Case Interview
  • Consulting Q&A
Popular in Finance
  • Finance Q&A
  • Interview in Investment Banking
  • Investment Banking Salaries
Popular in Consulting
  • Case Library
  • Meeting Board
  • Interview Partner
  • Case Interview Basics
  • Case Interview
  • Consulting Q&A
Popular in Finance
  • Finance Q&A
  • Interview in Investment Banking
  • Investment Banking Salaries
Consulting and Finance Employers
  • RWE Consulting
  • Whiteshield Advisory
  • All Employers »
About PrepLounge
  • For Companies
  • For Universities
  • For Coaches
  • About Us
  • Career
  • FAQ
© 2012 PrepLounge
Our servers are powered by electricity from renewable sources.
  • Cookies & Privacy
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Imprint
  • Sitemap
  • Contact
Facebook Linkedin Instagram TikTok Youtube
Questions or Feedback?
Select category
  • Select category
  • General Feedback
  • Case Interview Preparation
  • Coaching
  • Technical Problems
  • Other
Your name
Your email address
Cancel