Zurück zur Übersicht

External Consultancies 2024 | Wait or sign?

Hi everybody,

I was in a prestigous inhouse consultancy for quite a while now (2yrs) and want to move on now to an external consultancy.

 

With the given circumstances that MBB is not hiring at all, I only have 1 offer from a big4 strategy firm. (I have many more from boutiques & other firms, but that doesnt matter now). Should I sign that offer or wait until more opportunities come across throughout 2024?

I have to sign a contract until Q1 2025, but I also want clarity before that date.

32
10
2,5k
Beste Antwort
Profilbild von Ian
Ian
Coach
am 17. März 2024
Ex-BCG | NYU Stern | MBB, Tech, & Strategy Coach | 5,000+ Sessions | 500+ Offers | 1,000+ Candidates | 100+ Countries

MBB is hiring….

Actively…

1) I know candidates getting offers

2) From online research you can see hiring is happening

3) Even when firms fire, they also hire

My strong advice would be to sign the thing you have instead of wait for the thing you maybe possibly hopefully have.

Profilbild von bocokof
am 18. März 2024
good!
Anonym A
am 18. März 2024
I think your comment cant be applied for germany tho..
Profilbild von Ian
Ian
Coach
am 18. März 2024
Ex-BCG | NYU Stern | MBB, Tech, & Strategy Coach | 5,000+ Sessions | 500+ Offers | 1,000+ Candidates | 100+ Countries
Oh no, it still very much applies: https://www.preplounge.com/en/consulting-forum/is-there-a-hiring-freeze-at-mbb-17507
Du möchtest mehr zu diesem Thema erfahren oder an der Diskussion teilnehmen?
Registriere dich kostenlos bei PrepLounge und erhalte Zugang zu Wissen aus erster Hand von Consulting-Expert:innen, hilfreichen Materialien für deine Interviewvorbereitung und einer internationalen Community von Kandidat:innen. Werde Teil der größten Case-Interview-Community der Welt.
Profilbild von Niklas
Niklas
Coach
am 20. März 2024
McKinsey Jr. Engagement Manager | Interviewer at McK| Coached numerous candidates to secure MBB offers | University of Oxford

Congrats on getting offers! :)

I would do the move as this improves your chances of getting an offer from MBB in the future. 

Profilbild von Hagen
Hagen
Coach
am 30. Apr. 2024
Globally top-ranked MBB coach | >95% success rate | 9+ years consulting, interviewing and coaching experience

Hi there,

First of all, congratulations on the offer(s)!

I would be happy to share my thoughts on your situation:

  • First of all, almost all major strategy consulting firms (in Germany) are still hiring, albeit at a slower pace. Given this fact, it could be that your application was simply not strong enough, be it in terms of CV, cover letter and/ or referral.
  • Moreover, given the ban periods for almost all strategy consulting firms, I am not sure what other opportunities might arise in strategy consulting for the rest of the year.
  • Lastly, I would therefore advise you to consider accepting the offer from this strategy consulting firm very carefully.

If you would like a more detailed discussion on your specific situation, please don't hesitate to contact me directly.

Best,

Hagen

 

You can find the consulting salaries report 2024 here!

Profilbild von Florian
Florian
Coach
am 18. März 2024
Ex-McKinsey | 700+ offers for my clients | 1,600+ 5-star reviews across platforms | Top case interview book on Amazon

Hi there,

Congrats on your offers in this difficult market.

I would move to the other firm now as this further strengthens your profile for MBB next year, and then apply with MBB after one year.

Kind regards,

Florian

Anonym A
am 18. März 2024
Do you have any insights for the german market? I have applied for MBB but tomorrow supposed to be the day to start with solve and I didnt get any information yet about invitation or not.
Profilbild von Alberto
Alberto
Coach
am 18. März 2024
Ex-McKinsey AP | Professional MBB Coach | +13yrs experience | +2,000 real interviews | +150 offers

Hi there,

I can confirm as well from several coachees who recently got offers that MBB is hiring.

Based on what you shared, I suggest you take the best offer you have on the table if that improves you current position. Once you are there, you have a lot of time to work on your application strategy for MBB in the following moths.

Best,

Alberto

—

Check out my latest case based on a real MBB interview: Sierra Springs

Profilbild von Francesco
am 18. März 2024
#1 Coach for Sessions (4.500+) | 1.500+ 5-Star Reviews | Proven Success: ➡ interviewoffers.com | Ex BCG | 10Y+ Coaching

Hi there,

Congratulations on the offer! In terms of your question: 

Q: Should I sign that offer or wait until more opportunities come across throughout 2024?

If you have already applied to all the possible companies, and this is the best opportunity right now (compared also to your current employer), then I would go for it. If you still have applications ongoing/to complete, you might want to postpone signing/joining once you have completed the process with them, if possible.

Good luck!

Francesco

Profilbild von bocokof
am 18. März 2024

Good information! 

10
Profilbild von Udayan
Udayan
Coach
am 17. März 2024
Top Rated MBB coach | 300+ Real MBB offers | McKinsey Engagement Manager in NYC |15 Years Interviewing Experience

Did you try with MBB? From what I have seen, I also second Ian that hiring is picking up. It is of course nothing like 2022 but not as bad as 2023 either.

Anonym A
am 18. März 2024
I did, but still didnt get a response. Will wait few more days.
Profilbild von Pedro
Pedro
Coach
am 18. März 2024
BAIN | EY-Parthenon | Roland Berger | Former Principal | FIT & PEI Expert

If that is the best offer you have, I agree it can be a positive move towards MBB/Strategy Consulting.

The only piece of advice I would give would be to consider whether you prefer that Big4 role or staying where you are. If you are only moving as an intermediate step for something else, and the role by itself does not look more interesting to you than the one you have, then you should stay.

Profilbild von Cristian
am 18. März 2024
ex-McKinsey | Holistic approach | >400 clients coached

If you don't have to sign the contract until Q1, then I would keep an eye on the market, speak with the recruiters and if cool new opportunities pop up, then you should go for them. 

And in that case, you should make it clear to the recruiters that you have a competing offer that you need to respond to, and as a consequence, they should fast-track you through the recruitment process.

Best,

Cristian