McK PEI: "Problem Solving" as a separate PEI Dimension?

You did it! The lengthy interview preparation period is over, you've passed the tests before the actual interview and now you are sitting here in front of your interviewers. Your goal is, of course, to master every single question with excellence and to leave a positive impression.

Growth PyramidMcKinsey Growth Pyramid The so-called Growth Pyramid from McKinsey is a good way to explore the growth potentials of a company. Imagine standing in front of a group of experienced management consultants and having to present your vision for a company's growth. How do you proceed? The McKinsey Growth Pyramid helps you structure your thoughts and develop convincing growth strategies.The McKinsey Growth Pyramid is a strategic model developed in the 1980s by the renowned management consulting firm McKinsey & Company. It is designed to help companies identify growth opportunities. The pyramid consists of seven levels that represent different growth strategies - from market penetration to the development of new business models.The Seven Levels of the McKinsey Growth PyramidMarket Penetration:For example, market penetration is about maximizing the sale of your existing products in current markets. A practical example would be a software company that intensifies its marketing efforts to increase the usage rate of its apps. It could offer special promotions for existing customers or incentives for using additional features.Market Development:Market development aims to find new markets for existing products. For example, a company that manufactures children's toys might decide to market its products in a new country where it has not been present before to tap into new customer segments from there.Product Development: Here you develop new products for the markets in which you are already active. For example, a manufacturer of sportswear could introduce a new, innovative line of environmentally friendly, sustainable clothing to meet changing customer preferences and stand out from the competition.Diversification:Diversification means creating new products for new markets. A classic example is an electronics entertainment company that decides to enter the health market by developing fitness trackers. This often requires significant investments and market analysis, as it is a completely new area.Acquisition:Growth through acquisition can occur by purchasing another company that either operates in the same industry or offers complementary products. For example, a telecommunications provider might buy an internet service provider to expand its offerings and create synergies.Strategic Alliances:Strategic alliances or partnerships can also promote growth. An example would be an airline that forms an alliance with a car rental company to offer its customers a comprehensive travel package. Such collaborations can help the companies involved expand their reach and resources.New Business Models:Developing new business models is often the most creative and challenging growth strategy. An example would be a traditional book publisher that decides to create a self-publishing platform that allows authors to publish and market their works directly, representing a new source of revenue.Applying the Growth Pyramid in Case Interviews In case interviews, it is crucial that you present not only theoretical knowledge but also demonstrate how you can apply this knowledge in real business scenarios. Here are examples of how you could use each level of the Growth Pyramid in a case interview:Market Penetration: Suppose you are advising a coffeehouse chain operator who wants to increase its market share in a saturated urban environment. You could suggest increasing customer frequency through loyalty programs or increasing brand awareness through targeted advertising campaigns in local media and social networks.Market Development: Imagine you are working on a case for a manufacturer of power tools who wants to expand into new geographic markets. You could suggest tapping into emerging markets in Asia, where the construction industry is booming, highlighting local distribution partnerships as a key strategy.Product Development: You are advising a company in the consumer electronics sector that wants to expand its product portfolio. One option would be to develop smart home devices that are compatible with the company's existing technology to leverage the current customer base and create added value.Diversification: A pharmaceutical company is looking for growth opportunities outside its core competence. You could suggest diversification into the digital health applications sector to tap into new revenue streams and reduce dependence on traditional medications.Acquisition: Suppose a large retail company wants to expand its online business. You could recommend acquiring an emerging e-commerce startup to gain immediate access to advanced technology and an established customer base.Strategic Alliances: You are working with an airline that wants to expand its market presence. A strategic alliance with a global hotel network could offer customers added value while simultaneously increasing the brand reach of both companies.New Business Models: A traditional book publisher wants to reinvent itself in the digital age. You could suggest introducing a subscription model for e-books that offers readers unlimited access to a wide range of titles for a monthly fee.By using these business scenarios in your answers, you show that you are capable of applying the theoretical concepts of the Growth Pyramid in a practical and innovative way. This will not only demonstrate your analytical skills but also highlight your creativity and business understanding.Critical Consideration of the Growth Pyramid The Growth Pyramid or the 7S model, also developed by McKinsey, are strategic tools that help companies identify and analyze various growth strategies.Despite their popularity and widespread application, the Growth Pyramid has some limitations and criticisms: Limitations and Boundaries:Excessive Focus on Growth: The Growth Pyramid focuses heavily on growth as the primary goal, which in some cases can come at the expense of other important aspects such as sustainability, ethical action, or long-term stability.Complexity in Implementation: Applying the different levels of the pyramid can be complex, especially when it comes to integrating and coordinating various growth strategies.Dynamic Markets: The Growth Pyramid provides a static framework that may not be able to adapt quickly enough to changing market conditions and unforeseen events (see: VUCA).Internal Resistance: Growth strategies can encounter internal resistance, especially if they require significant changes in corporate culture or structure.Resource Constraints: Implementing growth strategies often requires significant resources, and not all companies have the necessary means to effectively use all levels of the pyramid.Criticism:One-Size-Fits-All: The Growth Pyramid offers a general approach that is not suitable for every company or situation. It does not consider the unique challenges or opportunities that arise from a company's specific industry or market environment.Lack of Flexibility: The pyramid can lead to a rigid mindset that excludes creative or unconventional growth strategies.Insufficient Emphasis on Risks: The Growth Pyramid can encourage companies to pursue growth at any cost without conducting adequate risk assessments.Alternative Frameworks or Models:Ansoff Matrix: A classic marketing tool that helps companies develop growth strategies based on existing and new markets and products.Porter's Five Forces Model: A framework for analyzing the competitive forces in an industry and identifying strategies to increase profitability.Blue Ocean Strategy: An approach that aims to create new markets or "blue oceans" that are free from competition, rather than competing in "red oceans" with intense competition.Balanced Scorecard: A strategic management tool that combines financial and non-financial performance indicators to provide a more balanced picture of company performance.Lean-Startup: An approach that promotes the development of new business models through rapid experimentation, customer feedback, and iterative product releases. These alternative models can be used alone or in combination with the Growth Pyramid, depending on the specific situation and goals of the company, to enable more comprehensive strategic planning.Conclusion on the Growth Pyramid The strength of the Growth Pyramid lies in its ability to provide a structured approach to the complex topic of corporate growth. It forces decision-makers to think beyond the obvious and consider both internal and external factors that can influence growth. This model is particularly useful for companies that want to develop a clear and comprehensive growth strategy that goes beyond simple financial goals.Comparison with Other McKinsey Frameworks and Models: The Growth Pyramid is one of several tools and frameworks developed by McKinsey to assist companies in strategy development. Each of these models has its own focus and scope of application:The 7S model focuses on the internal alignment of strategy, structure, systems, shared values, style, staff, and skills to achieve organizational effectiveness.The Ansoff Matrix helps companies identify growth strategies through market penetration, product development, market development, and diversification.McKinsey's Three Horizons Model allows companies to plan and prioritize their initiatives across short-, medium-, and long-term horizons. Compared to these other models, the Growth Pyramid offers a more specific framework for developing growth strategies. However, it is not without limitations and should not be viewed in isolation. In practice, it is often used in combination with other frameworks to develop a holistic strategy.For aspiring consultants, it is important to understand the Growth Pyramid, as it can be a useful tool for structuring thoughts and developing growth strategies in case interviews. At the same time, they should also familiarize themselves with other models to develop a flexible and comprehensive consulting competence capable of adapting to various customer requirements and market conditions.