expert
Expert with best answer

Clara

100% Recommendation Rate

39 Meetings

4,341 Q&A Upvotes

USD 209 / Coaching

7

Consulting firm referral strategy

I have read the posts about referral on this forum, but still have some specific questions:

1. Currently, I am applying for MBB. For a specific firm, how many referrals would you try to secure? My original plan was to secure 2 people each firm to refer me, and send my CV to both to just make sure that the referral is completed. Should I just ask one person to refer, given that there might be an issue of referral bonus if I asked two people to refer for me?

2. It seems that firms like McKinsey have a referral system where you need to fill in specific reason why you think the candidate is a good fit. My question is, given that reason for referral needs to be provided (instead of just forwarding application to HR), is it still logical to cold mail to find a person who could refer me? Even if I successfully had a quick chat on phone with an employee, it's hard for him to provide solid reasons of why he should recommend me.

3. I have spent a lot of time sending cold mails and asking for phone chat. But some of my friends mentioned that they would prefer referring people (to earn the $) but wouldn't want to spend time to chat. Is it recommended to directly cold mail and ask the employee whether he could refer me (of course, crafting a nice mail mentioning about my background and motivation)?

Any suggestion would be appreciated. Thanks a lot!

I have read the posts about referral on this forum, but still have some specific questions:

1. Currently, I am applying for MBB. For a specific firm, how many referrals would you try to secure? My original plan was to secure 2 people each firm to refer me, and send my CV to both to just make sure that the referral is completed. Should I just ask one person to refer, given that there might be an issue of referral bonus if I asked two people to refer for me?

2. It seems that firms like McKinsey have a referral system where you need to fill in specific reason why you think the candidate is a good fit. My question is, given that reason for referral needs to be provided (instead of just forwarding application to HR), is it still logical to cold mail to find a person who could refer me? Even if I successfully had a quick chat on phone with an employee, it's hard for him to provide solid reasons of why he should recommend me.

3. I have spent a lot of time sending cold mails and asking for phone chat. But some of my friends mentioned that they would prefer referring people (to earn the $) but wouldn't want to spend time to chat. Is it recommended to directly cold mail and ask the employee whether he could refer me (of course, crafting a nice mail mentioning about my background and motivation)?

Any suggestion would be appreciated. Thanks a lot!

7 answers

  • Upvotes
  • Date ascending
  • Date descending
Best Answer
Book a coaching with Clara

100% Recommendation Rate

39 Meetings

4,341 Q&A Upvotes

USD 209 / Coaching

Hello!

To your points:

  1. You only need 1 referral per MBB firm -as you said, you don´t wan to generate friction in case of a referral bonus-.
  2. Precisely for this is best to ensure that you get the know the person before. Think that the referral is linked to their name, so they also need to indeed check if you would be a good fit. Best is to have the possibility to meet, even briefly (e.g., coffee chat, recruitment event, etc.)
  3. Don´t ask direclty in the first interaction. Stablish a communication line and only then tackle the topic, so you leave the other person the chance to "take the lead" and propose the way he/she wants to go.

Hope it helps!

Cheers,
Clara

Hello!

To your points:

  1. You only need 1 referral per MBB firm -as you said, you don´t wan to generate friction in case of a referral bonus-.
  2. Precisely for this is best to ensure that you get the know the person before. Think that the referral is linked to their name, so they also need to indeed check if you would be a good fit. Best is to have the possibility to meet, even briefly (e.g., coffee chat, recruitment event, etc.)
  3. Don´t ask direclty in the first interaction. Stablish a communication line and only then tackle the topic, so you leave the other person the chance to "take the lead" and propose the way he/she wants to go.

Hope it helps!

Cheers,
Clara

Book a coaching with Emily

100% Recommendation Rate

23 Meetings

2,054 Q&A Upvotes

USD 179 / Coaching

Hi,

(1) Defitinte just 1 per company, otherwise you create unnecessary trouble for all people involved
(2) That's why a good referral is never just about 1 email or 1 call. You need to invest time in building relationship and get the person to know you more so that he/she can actually speak well for you. Otherwise even if he/she fill the form, their answer might not be convincing.
(3) No. In more cases I would think the person wouldn't feel comfortable doing so. There might be some consultants who prefer referring without knowing you because they just want to take a chance on the $. But I can tell you the success rate with such referral would be pretty low. People who refer for the sake of money without quality check are most likely to be junior and transactional in the company. Senior people and people who would stay in the company know when they refer someone they are taking a risk with their own credibility.

Best,

Emily

Hi,

(1) Defitinte just 1 per company, otherwise you create unnecessary trouble for all people involved
(2) That's why a good referral is never just about 1 email or 1 call. You need to invest time in building relationship and get the person to know you more so that he/she can actually speak well for you. Otherwise even if he/she fill the form, their answer might not be convincing.
(3) No. In more cases I would think the person wouldn't feel comfortable doing so. There might be some consultants who prefer referring without knowing you because they just want to take a chance on the $. But I can tell you the success rate with such referral would be pretty low. People who refer for the sake of money without quality check are most likely to be junior and transactional in the company. Senior people and people who would stay in the company know when they refer someone they are taking a risk with their own credibility.

Best,

Emily

Book a coaching with Antonello

98% Recommendation Rate

101 Meetings

1,539 Q&A Upvotes

USD 219 / Coaching

1. 1 per firm
2. yes
3. I would use LinkedIn, starting from ex alumni of your university now in MBB

1. 1 per firm
2. yes
3. I would use LinkedIn, starting from ex alumni of your university now in MBB

Book a coaching with Luca

100% Recommendation Rate

22 Meetings

1,935 Q&A Upvotes

USD 179 / Coaching

Hello,

Here are my answers:

1) One referral per company is absolutely enough. It codul be ambarassing for people inside to refer the same person (when you refer someone you should know him quite well..)

2) Yes, it is. If they believe that you are a good candidate it's a win-win situation, you get the job and they get the referral bonus

3) An email could be enough to start. Then, if you are ale to establish a connection, you could ask for a quick phone call to thank him.

Best,
Luca

Hello,

Here are my answers:

1) One referral per company is absolutely enough. It codul be ambarassing for people inside to refer the same person (when you refer someone you should know him quite well..)

2) Yes, it is. If they believe that you are a good candidate it's a win-win situation, you get the job and they get the referral bonus

3) An email could be enough to start. Then, if you are ale to establish a connection, you could ask for a quick phone call to thank him.

Best,
Luca

Book a coaching with Francesco

100% Recommendation Rate

2,859 Meetings

5,536 Q&A Upvotes

USD 349 / Coaching

Hi Anonymous,

please find below the replies to your questions:

  1. You just need one referral for each firm, the higher in the ranking the better
  2. I helped a lot of candidates who managed to get referrals with the right cold email, I would not worry about that
  3. You should not send messages asking for a referral directly – it is highly unlikely it could work and you could annoy people

Best,

Francesco

Hi Anonymous,

please find below the replies to your questions:

  1. You just need one referral for each firm, the higher in the ranking the better
  2. I helped a lot of candidates who managed to get referrals with the right cold email, I would not worry about that
  3. You should not send messages asking for a referral directly – it is highly unlikely it could work and you could annoy people

Best,

Francesco

Book a coaching with Ian

100% Recommendation Rate

53 Meetings

2,765 Q&A Upvotes

USD 239 / Coaching

First, remember that this is a small world and life is long. In general, carry yourself high and hold yourself to the rules....people talk and find out if you've been sneaky about things. All of your questions start from the wrong premise, in my opinion (which is, get in at all costs). Do it the right way or not at all.

However, to answer your questions:

1) One only (pick the person you know the best and/or the most senior).

2) I can't imagine someone referring you without knowing you - they have a reputation to uphold as well. However, If you spoke with them on a call or during a coffee chat, they would have enough to go off of.

3) No. Your name is tied to that request! Also, in general, don't ask for recommendations when first speaking to someone who has given you their time. If someone doesn't want to recommend you, they won't. If they did, this could likely turn them off. Let it come from them.

First, remember that this is a small world and life is long. In general, carry yourself high and hold yourself to the rules....people talk and find out if you've been sneaky about things. All of your questions start from the wrong premise, in my opinion (which is, get in at all costs). Do it the right way or not at all.

However, to answer your questions:

1) One only (pick the person you know the best and/or the most senior).

2) I can't imagine someone referring you without knowing you - they have a reputation to uphold as well. However, If you spoke with them on a call or during a coffee chat, they would have enough to go off of.

3) No. Your name is tied to that request! Also, in general, don't ask for recommendations when first speaking to someone who has given you their time. If someone doesn't want to recommend you, they won't. If they did, this could likely turn them off. Let it come from them.

(edited)

Book a coaching with Vlad

97% Recommendation Rate

388 Meetings

7,305 Q&A Upvotes

USD 299 / Coaching

Hi,

1) Only one person can refer you and get a bonus. There is absolutely 0 sense to have more than one. Pls don't confuse the people who will be referring you and spending their time

2) Technically you can provide some fake reasons for him. Especially if you have some touch points (same university). However cold calling is always the worst and the least efficient

3) Pls never do that. You never know how the person will react (he can simply report you to hr

Best

Hi,

1) Only one person can refer you and get a bonus. There is absolutely 0 sense to have more than one. Pls don't confuse the people who will be referring you and spending their time

2) Technically you can provide some fake reasons for him. Especially if you have some touch points (same university). However cold calling is always the worst and the least efficient

3) Pls never do that. You never know how the person will react (he can simply report you to hr

Best

Thanks Vlad. Regarding the third point, you mean for cold mailing, it is always suggested to request a phone call as a start right? — Anonymous A on Feb 12, 2020

Yes — Vlad on Feb 13, 2020