Re-application to MBB after being counseled to leave.

Question

Hey all,

I am reaching out to seek your advice on the possibility of rejoining an MBB firm in the same geographic area, having previously been counseled to leave in 2020.

My tenure at MBB spanned from 2019 to 2020, and my departure was officially attributed to performance issues during the uncertain times of the pandemic. Notably, a significant part of my time was spent unstaffed, affecting my professional development compared to peers.

Since leaving MBB, I have been part of an internal strategy team in the industry, predominantly composed of former MBB consultants. My performance has consistently been highly rated, and I have recently been promoted to a managerial role.

Given this context, I would appreciate your insight into whether a successful re-application to an MBB firm is feasible, considering my improved track record and the unique circumstances of my earlier exit.

Thank you very much!

Answer 1

Hi there,

Two things -

I would encourage you to think hard about why you want to join MBB again since you are doing well and growing in your current role. Not only this is important for the re-application process (they will ask you), but also important for yourself, so you are making an informed decision that you can live with and maximise career success over the long term
You can definitely apply again (even to the same firm), but you need to show that you have improved significantly since you left and have a compelling “come back” story. This is doable but requires some networking (either with old colleagues or folks at different firms). I would also add that the market demand for consultants would really impact how open potential firms are to accepting you

Happy to connect and discuss a strategy in depth

Answer 2

Is there a reason you want to go back, especially given that you're doing well and are liked by your team?

In terms of going back - of course it's possible but not for the firm you were counseled to leave. For other firms you will need to build a network and leverage that to apply. In terms of timing however I would say this is not a great year. All the firms are looking to get more consultants to leave given over hiring so it will be more challenging than 2019 to get your foot in the door again especially if you have to explain a CTL decision.

Answer 3

Hi there,

First of all, I am sorry to hear about your negative experience with that MBB firm in the past!

I would be happy to share my thoughts on your situation:

First of all, it is certainly possible with the other two MBB firms, yet it may be tough with your past employer, whether there actually was a performance issue or not.
Moreover, however, I am wondering why you want to go back to consulting if you are obviously doing great work at your current employer.

If you would like a more detailed discussion on your specific situation, please don't hesitate to contact me directly.

Best,

Hagen

You can find the consulting salaries report 2024 here!

Answer 4

As other coaches mention, I suggest to think twice before coming back again. That sounds as a step back in your career from the outside.

Also I see it hard the hire you back after a CTL. Never heard this case before.

Best,

Alberto

—

Check out my latest case based on a real MBB interview: Sierra Springs

Answer 5

Sorry to hear about your situation.

But yes, you can definitely transition back.

And you should present your story just like you did here. Transparently. And with vulnerability.

Everybody loves a great transformation story. And you have one.

Make sure that you manage to convey it in both your application documents (CV, CL) and your interactions (chats with HR and current consultants who might provide you with a referral).

Keeping my fingers crossed for you!
Best,
Cristian

Answer 6

For other firms yes, it is possible.

For the same firm… you have been there… it has to be through networking with the people you know there from that period.