Deciding on offer: Guidance on decision Matrix

Anonymous A asked on Feb 15, 2019 - 1 answer

Hey Everyone!

First of all, thank everyone in general, particularly preplounge leaders and experts for the preparation material available as well as the insights shared. It has proven very useful for me throughout recruitment processes.

I am now in the process of deciding which offer to take from the following options:

  • Simon Kucher & Partners in Dubai
  • Simon Kucher & Partners in Madrid, Spain
  • EY Parthenon in Mexico City

I would very much appreciate your input and thoughts to help me decide which offer would be best to take and feedback on the decision matrix I have come up with. This is based, in order of highest to lowest importance, on 4 factors:

  1. Career Goals (alignment between opportunities at the firm and its position with my future career goals)
  2. Fit (personal and cultural synergies with firm and consultants, as I believe this relates to the potential for me to thrive)
  3. Mobility (international transfer options and project exposure)
  4. Personal Satisfaction (location, main industries covered, personal interests, type of projects, etc.)

I would also appreciate any information on how the above firms and offices are perceived in the consulting industry internationally (reputation) and if they seem like solid options to make a jump to MBB or to course an MBA at a top university in the near future (2-3 years).

Lastly, I would like to ask on how to handle a rejection in the best possible way for the offers I don't end up taking.

Thank you very much in advance!

1 answer

  • Upvotes
  • Date ascending
  • Date descending
replied on Apr 05, 2019
McKinsey Associate | Coached 80+ MBB candidates | INSEAD MBA & CDI MBA
Book a coaching with Alberto

3 Meetings

12 Q&A Upvotes

USD 109 / Coaching

Hi Anonymous,

glad to hear that you got 3 offers!
Actually, your question on the selection process is really specific and it requires a tailored approach.
I would suggest you do a problem-solving session with an expert. He would collect all the input (e.g., your personal driving forces and constraints) to guide you in such an important decision. The answer you can find on the Q&A are most of the time on general topics, and you wouldn't be able to extract a proper value from them.

Good luck!