- Knowing your case
- Being able to answer clarifying questions
- Being able to "make up" reasonable answers where none are written
- Being able to follow the candidate's math, and challenge where needed
- Being flexible in the case flow (based on what they ask in what order)
- Challenge their thinking
- "Guide" but don't lead
- Change the case to test aspects where needed
- Make the case "harder" when/where needed
- Providing thorough feedback at the end (by "section" of the case AND judgement criteria)
Back to overview
10
What makes a good case interviewer?
2
1.7k
Be the first to answer!
Nobody has responded to this question yet.
Top answer
Ian
on Oct 13, 2020
Coach
Top US BCG / MBB Coach - 5,000 sessions |Tech, Platinion, Big 4 | 9/9 personal interviews passed | 95% candidate success
0 comments
Robert
on Oct 13, 2020
Coach
McKinsey offers w/o final round interviews - 100% risk-free - 10+ years MBB coaching experience - Multiple book author
Hi Zach,
Beyound the obvious, an experienced (=good) interviewer has the following skills:
- Have the case running in any direction, without sticking to a pre-defined solution, depending on how the candidate sets up the structure and thinks about the question (it's not always right or wrong in a case interview - oftenly it depends on how you interpret some data, and I don't like to redirect candidates if they have solid argumentation into a specific direction).
- Challenging candidates' thought process and decision-making rationale, even if it's going into the right dimension. By that also making sure that it wasn't a lucky punch, but a clear solid thinking which led the candidate to some conclusion.
- Differentiating between not being comfortable with numbers and making a simple math calculation mistake. The big picture counts, obviously it's not good to make math mistakes, but I don't care if I see that you are doing well with numbers and have made somewhere a small mistake in a calculation (this topic is way to over-hyped..).
- Building high-pressure situations within the interview without being offensive towards the candidate. Yes, it's part of real-life situations that's why it's absolutely legitimate to test a candidate under pressure - but there is no point in being personally offensive towards a candidates.
Hope this helps - if so, please be so kind to give it a thumbs-up with the green upvote button below!
Robert
Similar Questions
Most Popular Posts
Should an aspiring consultant apply to 100 companies or just to 10 targeted companies? Kindly elaborate for each option. Open for additional advice.
9
on Nov 25, 2025
UK
8
100+
Top answer by
Jade
Coach
Bain ⎮ MBB & 2nd Tier offer holder ⎮ 100% success rate so far! You can do it too
8 Answers
100+ Views
+5
BCG SEA R1 - Experienced Hire
9
on Nov 26, 2025
Asia
9
100+
Top answer by
Ariadna
Coach
BCG London | Project Leader and Experienced Interviewer | MBA at London Business School
9 Answers
100+ Views
+6
Hi, which consulting firms should I be considering applying to as an experienced hire working in healthcare?
15
on Nov 28, 2025
UK
8
100+
Top answer by
Kevin
Coach
Ex-Bain (London) | Private Equity & M&A | 12+ Yrs Experience | The Reflex Method | Free Intro Call
8 Answers
100+ Views
+5
BCG prep after McKinsey rejection after R2
11
on Nov 30, 2025
Europe
7
100+
Top answer by
Pedro
Coach
BAIN | EY-P | Most Senior Coach @ Preplounge | Former Principal | FIT & PEI Expert
7 Answers
100+ Views
+4
MBB Exit chances after being counseled out
9
on Dec 01, 2025
Global
5
100+
Top answer by
Tiago
Coach
Harvard MBA | ex-BCG Consultant | BCG Recruiting Team & Interviewer | +150 interviews
5 Answers
100+ Views
+2