Mckinsey or MBA?

This is a good problem to have, but you need to handle it carefully.

the 3-month stint question

Joining for 3 months and then resigning is not ideal, but it is not career-ending either. McKinsey invests heavily in onboarding a new associate, so leaving after 3 months will leave a bad taste. Your cohort will remember it, and consulting is a small world. That said, people have done it and survived professionally.

i suggest instead

Talk to your recruiter or HR contact before you start. Ask directly whether they offer a deferral or can convert your offer to a pre-MBA internship track. McKinsey has done this before, especially for HBS and GSB admits, because they know those alumni are valuable long-term relationships. The worst they can say is no, and you are no worse off than if you had said nothing.

• Do not resign the offer speculatively. You have not been admitted yet.
• Wait until you have an admit letter in hand before having any conversation with McKinsey.
• If admitted, approach McKinsey immediately and frame it as wanting to maintain the relationship, not as choosing the school over them.
• If they say no to deferral, then you make a clean decision: McKinsey now or MBA. Both are strong paths.

Congrats for both opportunities; being in that position is already a great achievement.

The only strong suggestion I can give is to avoid joining McKinsey for just a couple of months and then resigning. That is probably the fastest way to burn any future opportunity with them and McKinsey tends to have a long memory with these things.

If I were in your position, I would be open with both the MBA program and McKinsey about your situation. It is actually a bit of a badge of honor to be choosing between these options, and transparency usually works better than trying to manage it quietly.

I would try to explore one of these two options.

1. Ask the MBA program for a deferral.
   At the same time, be transparent with McKinsey and ask whether they would be comfortable with you joining now and then taking leave for the MBA in about a year or so, possibly returning afterward.
2. Ask McKinsey to defer your start date until after the MBA.
   You could also propose committing to do a summer internship with them during the MBA, which sometimes makes the arrangement easier.

Honestly, I do not see sponsorship of the MBA from McKinsey as very likely in this case. Typically they reserve sponsorship for high-performing consultants who joined after undergrad, using it as a retention and reward mechanism. At least that was they did with me when I was sponsored my MBA.

Hope it helps!

Franco

Hi,

That's a very cool problem to have — congratulations on both fronts! Some of my friends have gone through the same dilemma, so let me share a few ideas:

Please do not join for 3 months and then resign. You don't want to quite McKinsey after three months (I spent 7 years at McKinsey :)) 

The best options:

1. Defer your school admission. Both HBS and GSB allow deferrals — it is more common than you think. You go into business school with real experience under your belt, which makes the whole MBA far more valuable.

2. Join McKinsey, work for 1-2 years, then get McKinsey to sponsor your MBA. This is the golden path — McKinsey has a well-established sponsorship program. Several of my colleagues have done exactly this. They get their tuition covered (fully or substantially), a guaranteed return offer as a post-MBA Associate, and two years of savings in the bank before school. You solve the financial concern and come out ahead in every way.

3. Be upfront with McKinsey. Once you have the admission, tell your recruiter or HR contact something like: "I am fully committed to joining. I have also received an admission to HBS/GSB and plan to defer. I would love to discuss the MBA sponsorship pathway in due course." This is a conversation McKinsey has all the time — they will not be surprised and they will respect the transparency.

On the pre-MBA internship idea: Converting a full-time offer into a short internship is not really a thing at McKinsey. It would be an awkward ask. The deferral route is much cleaner and better for everyone.

Bottom line: Join McKinsey, do great work for a year or two, defer the school, and let McKinsey cover it for you.

Having said all that, if you've gotten into McKinsey and you have HBS interviews lined up, you seem like a pretty smart kid. I'm positive that you'll make the best of the blessings you have anyway (in the grand scheme of things, you'll do well either way!)

Hope that helps! Happy to chat more if you want to think through specifics :)

All the best!

This is a good problem to have, but do not get ahead of yourself. You have not been admitted yet. Wait until you actually have an offer before making any decisions.

If you do get in, three months at McKinsey and then resigning is not ideal but it is not career-ending either. People have done it. That said, it burns goodwill with a firm you may want to return to post-MBA, and McKinsey does hire back a lot of its own alumni.

The better path is to have an honest conversation with your McKinsey recruiter if and when you get an admit. Ask directly whether deferral or a pre-MBA internship conversion is possible. Some offices accommodate this, some do not. You will not know unless you ask, and asking is not the same as burning a bridge.

Do not resign without having that conversation first.

For now, focus on the HBS and GSB interviews. Cross the McKinsey bridge only if you actually get there.

Hi! firstly congrats, and you are in a great position! 

I would definitely recommend against joining McK and then resigning in 3 months. This will not be a value-add for you or the firm, and returning to the firm subsequently may become challenging. 

I would recommend either of the following: 

- an honest conversation with the McK team about your MBA aspirations only once you have the offer(s). Consulting firms are generally supportive of an MBA so this will not reflect poorly on you. You can have a conversation about how you are motivated to pursue an MBA, would love their sponsorship for a top program such as HBS/GSB, and then negotiate your title/promotion timeline - something like your willingness to return to McK as a Junior Associate post MBA for a few months (Vs. associate, but in return for a guaranteed role) and then being promoted to Associate based on your work (which is the normal post MBA position). You can also talk about doing your summer internship with them or in an industry that you can see yourself being affiliated to with McK in the future. Overall positioning this as how you will be a better consultant at McK if given the opportunity to pursue an MBA now 

- an honest conversation with the MBA programs about how you would like to defer the program to gain business experience that will make you stronger as a peer and help you bring more value to your classroom and cohort. McK's reputation and close ties with MBA programs should make this conversation a bit easier 

How you choose one over the other will depend on what you are keen to do at the moment and your vision for your career. Happy to chat in detail and good luck!