From online to offline

Solved 2.5k times
4.2 5 158

Problem Definition

We are thinking of establishing a door-to-door distribution of an existing online newspaper in Kolkata, India. We haven't spent much time on how the process would work in practice yet. Can you help us evaluate the feasibilty of the plan?


The case is designed to be presented to the candidate by an interviewer, who plays the role of a person has come up with a plan to establish a door-to-door distribution of an existing online newspaper.

This is a candidate-led case; therefore the candidate should lead the case from start to finish.

Short Solution (Expand)

Detailed Solution

Paragraphs highlighted in green indicate diagrams or tables that can be shared in the “Case exhibits” section.

Paragraphs highlighted in blue can be verbally communicated to the interviewee.

I. Background

Provide the following information to the interviewee if requested:

  • We do not have the resources to hire more than 10 newspaper carriers on bicycles
  • One carrier will have to distribute newspapers to all the houses in 1 square kilometer area within the city
  • In order to meet customer requirements, the carriers will have to distribute all the newspapers in 3 hours

Assumptions which the candidate can make:

  • Kolkata is in the shape of a square and all the houses are evenly distributed and equidistant (10 metres) from each other
  • All the non-residential areas should be ignored

Share diagram 1 with the candidate if deemed necessary,

II. Solution

To check the feasibility of the plan, let us calculate how quickly the newspaper carrier will have to deliver a newspaper.

Each side of the area will contain 1000m/10m or 100 houses. Therefore, in total a carrier will have to distribute newspapers to a total of 100*100 or 10,000 houses.

But since a single carrier only has 3 hours or 10,800 (3*60*60) seconds, he will have to distribute one newspaper in 10,000/10,800 second.

The plan seems infeasible as delivering a newspaper in less than a second is nearly impossible.

In such a scenario hiring more newspaper carriers should be the best alternative; but since we have budget constraints, we could consider the following:

  • Reduce distribution area
  • Change distribution method

III. Conclusion

It is an infeasible plan as it is impossible to deliver more than one newspaper in a second. The client should consider reducing the distribution area or changing the distribution method for the plan to become feasible.

Difficult Questions

How do we reduce the distribution area?

One way could be by delivering only to the most profitable potential customers.

Can you suggest a different distribution method?

The client could co-distribute with other publications or agencies.

Related consulting question(s)

Hey, I am new to this too, but I think I have some ideas for your problem. Your approach looks good, but I think you have a mistake in how you time the trains. You say that there is one train e... (more)

What should be framework for following: Client is a regional retail chain. They want to reduce their supply chain cost. 
Francesco gave the best answer on Aug 01, 2017 - 3 answers
#1 Expert for Coaching Sessions (2.100+) | 1.000+ Reviews with 100% Recommendation Rate | Ex BCG | 6 Years Coaching Experience
Book a coaching with Francesco

100% Recommendation Rate

2,178 Meetings

2,289 Q&A Upvotes

USD 319 / Coaching

Hi Aditya, I would suggest you the following points to start the structure: Identify the main revenue streams of the client Understand which revenue stream has an abnormal cost compared to... (more)

Estimate the market size of the cement industry of your country?
Vlad gave the best answer on Feb 18, 2018 - 2 answers
McKinsey / Accenture / Got all BIG3 offers / More than 300 real MBB cases / Harvard Business School
Book a coaching with Vlad

97% Recommendation Rate

340 Meetings

4,331 Q&A Upvotes

USD 319 / Coaching

Hi, I would also take into account several factors: What about apartment buildings? Why do you think there are only houses? I would calculate the number of buildings taking into account the a... (more)

No expert by any means but in an estimation question is always good to end with a sanity check. In this case, the sanity check could be that according to Dominic Barton (McKinsey's global managing... (more)

Hi Marilena, good question. I would always structure such a case completely top down. E.g. in your case, start with the population, then % of people needing glasses, % of those in reach of your... (more)

4.2 (158 ratings)
4.2 5 158
Case exhibits