Case

Nutripremium

Solved 20.5k times | Rating: (4.5 / 5.0) 400 |

Problem Definition

Nutripremium is a very well-known premium nutrition food company in Europe (€1 billion revenue last year). It is based in Spain and has an excellent market share not only in its home country but also in Portugal, France, Italy and Germany.

Nutripremium has two main lines of products:

  • Vitamin-supplements for pregnant women
  • Concentrated dehydrated aliments and vitamin pills for sick patients (with Diabetes or Cancer).

The CEO of Nutripremium thinks that the market in Europe is starting to get saturated and wants you to analyze the Chinese market.

What are the key areas you would explore to determine whether this is a good idea?


Comments

This case has been applied by McKinsey in a first round interview. As usual, McKinsey cases are interviewer-led.

That means that the interviewee gets several intermediate questions from the interviewer and has therefore to worry a bit less with the overall case structure than during an candidate-led interview (usual at consulting firms other than McKinsey).

As the interviewer, you have the choice to let the interviewee lead the case (letting him follow his own framework), or lead yourself the direction of the case (for example by following the suggested approach).


Short Solution

Nutripremium should not expand to the Chinese market.


Detailed Solution

Paragraphs highlighted in green indicate diagrams or tables that can be shared in the “Case exhibits” section.

Paragraphs highlighted in blue can be verbally communicated to the interviewee.

Paragraphs highlighted in orange indicate hints for you how to guide the interviewee through the case.

Suggested case structure:

Diagram 1

I. Market Analysis

Here the interviewee should dive into the potential of the new market.

  • Usage of such products by customers
  • Willingness to pay by customers
  • Total market size for each of Nutripremium’s product lines
  • Customer segments
  • Market trends

Share Table 1 with the interviewee and ask him to calculate the potential market for pregnant women products and for sick patients.

With the given information it should be possible to estimate the total market:

Pregnant women market

Assume that, on average, a Chinese woman has 2 babies in her lifetime (pregnancy: 18 months = 1½ years).

If we assume a life expectancy of 75 years, then we have on average 2% of all female population pregnant at a given time.

1

Assuming the population of China has 1.5 billion people and that 50% of the population are women, we then have 15 million pregnant women.
Out of these, only 10% consume special nutrition foods, i.e. 1.5 million women.

1.5 b x 50% x 2%= 0.015 b * 10% = 0.0015 b = 1.5 m

With an average expenditure of €150 per woman per year, the total market for pregnant women is then €225 million per year.

1.5 m * €150 = €225 m

Sick patients market

Using a similar estimation strategy, we can assume that on average 2% of the population has cancer at some time in their lives and on average for a duration of 5 years (after that they either are cured or passed away).

We have then, at a given time around 0.13% of the population sick of cancer (2% of (5 years/ 75 years)), around 2 million people.

To simplify the calculation, we assume 10 times more people have diabetes, i.e. 20 million people.
So we have a total of 22 million sick people. Out of these, we assume that about 10% of the sick patients actually use special nutrition products. The total market is then:

22 m * 10% * 300 €/person = €660 m

The total market for sick patients is €660 m per year.

The interviewee should also come to the conclusion (by asking whether the customers in China would like to buy the same product sold currently in Europe) that new types of products would need to be created to suit the Chinese taste.

The costs for this would be around €2 m.

II. Company

Here the candidate should inquire about the company’s capabilities of expanding to a new market abroad.

  • Company’s capabilities and expertise
  • Capacity to serve the Chinese market
  • Money needed to invest in the market expansion
  • Would the company continue producing in Spain to export to China? Probably not, as food is somewhat heavy and the shipping cost would most likely make the product too expensive for China.

Information that can be shared if the interviewee specifically asks for it:

  • Nutripremium had been consistently expanding its production capacity. However, since the European market showed signs of slowing down 3 years ago, it stopped the production capacity extension. Factories are now being run at 98% of capacity.
  • Nutripremium has no distribution channels nowadays in China. In Europe it sells its “Pregnant women” line in retail stores and its “Sick patients” line through hospitals and treatment centers.
  • A new factory in Spain that produces €100 m worth of products per year would require €500 m investment. The same factory in China would cost €300 m.
  • The company has around €600 m available for investments in its expansion.

Key insights

  • Capacity of factories is being used to 98% today. An expansion to a new market would require investments in one or more new factories. Since the factories are supposed to serve the Chinese market and building a factory there is cheaper than in Spain, the factory should be built in China.
  • The infrastructure investments of €300 m would cover 11% of the Chinese market.

5

  • The company has enough money available to build 2 such factories and a chance of 22% market share.
  • A lot of money and effort would have to be invested in building networks and contacts so that Nutripremium manages to engage the necessary distribution channels in China.

III. Competition

This is the most important part of the case. Although the market seems promising from its size and growth, the assessment of the competitive landscape should compel the candidate to take a position against the expansion.

  • Competition landscape for the products in China (monopolies, cartels)
  • Special regulations or other entry barriers
  • Market saturation

Share Diagram 2 and 3 with the interviewee to explain the competitive environment.

It is evident that there are three main competitors and that the government holds big shares in them.

Therefore the interviewer should share the following information if the candidate asks:

  • The market of special nutrition food is new in China. Old regulations contrary to it have been dropped upon Chinfoo’s request. Lobbying by Chinfoo (government is major shareholder) has been essential for the regulation-cancellation.
  • Competitors are building at the time 4 new special nutrition food factories.
  • Nutripremium’s more advanced technology would allow it to produce 10% cheaper than the current competitors in China.

Key insights

  • There appears to be a semi-monopoly in the market.
  • The government seems to be highly involved as a shareholder in the main competitors. This does not seem like a good panorama for a competitor coming from abroad and aiming at stealing market share from local players.
  • Competitors are expanding capacity which might lead to a decrease in market price (more offer).

IV. Conclusion

At the end of the case interview, the interviewee should wrap up the case referring back to the main findings throughout the case in a summarized and logical way.

A possible closing to this case could be:

I think Nutripremium should not expand to the Chinese market at this moment for 3 main reasons:

  • The competition seems to be fierce and government-controlled. The biggest three players in the market hold 90% of the market share. Government has 49% of shares of the biggest player, which would definitely bring us disadvantages in many circumstances (getting licenses, paperwork and bureaucracy for commercializing our products among others).
  • Since we are producing near to capacity, we would need to make new investments in infrastructure (build new factories). Although we do have the money for that, doing it in a very different market from ours – where the customer’s taste is different and where we have no experience of manufacturing our products – could end up being a problem if we fail to adapt.
  • There must be other markets where the competition is more diluted among more players and where the market has still a big size and potential for growth.
    Emerging countries in South America like Argentina and Brazil are a good example of possible candidates. The population has also more similar tastes to Europe than in China. The investment could yield a much better return in these countries.

Difficult Questions

How many cancer patients would we need to have for our cancer product to break even?

We have 25 Sales Reps (earning €200 k each) and spend €10 m in other indirect costs. We assume each patient takes 4 doses per day for 4 months. A dose costs €1 and its profit margin is 20%.

Suggested answer:

We have a total cost of € 15m (10m + 200k * 25) excluding the direct costs of the doses.

€10m + 200k * 25 = €15m

The number of doses a client takes per year is 480 (4 * 30 * 4).

6

Since the margin is 20% for each dose, each customer means a profit per year of around €100.

7We conclude than that we need approximately 150,000 customers for break-even in our cancer product.

8

More questions to be added by you, interviewer!

At the end of the case, you will have the opportunity to suggest challenging questions about this case (to be asked for instance if the next interviewees solve the case very fast).

Related consulting question(s)

As you describe it, this is the longest version of this case format; normally too long for an oral interview, so it's super important to listen whether the question is about if (the client should ente... (more)

Best answer so far out of 2 answers:

If I understand your questions correctly, you are trying to figure out the difference between analyzing the overall market (or an industry), vs. the subsections of the market that a particular company... (more)

Hi there, I would start by asking some general questions to have a better feeling on the case: 1) Does our client provides this new service elsewhere? If not, does our client already has the cap... (more)

Hi Marilena, good question. I would always structure such a case completely top down. E.g. in your case, start with the population, then % of people needing glasses, % of those in reach of your... (more)

There is a MECE answer provided to this by Nuno if market sizing is part of a market entry case. I believe this question is straight at market sizing, so i will provide my thoughts to this. I as... (more)

Related BootCamp article(s)

Approaching a Case

In order to get into consulting, the case study is the most important element of the interview. Here, you can learn the specific skills and concepts to solve them.

7 Comment(s)

Important Facts

It's essential to know some key figures regarding geographies, population, economies for your case interviews. We summarized them for you here.

9 Comment(s)

Market Entry

Market Entry Strategy Frameworks may be a great solution to apply in your Case Interview if your client is searching for growth alternatives.

2 Comment(s)

Market Sizing

Market Sizing Cases are used to test your quantitative and reasoning skills. The interviewer evaluates your structure, numbers-handling and business sense.

11 Comment(s)

Cost-Benefit Analysis

Investments or single business cases need to be evaluated based on a certain set of criteria. Since financial performance is the key criterion in most cases you need to have an idea about future financial impacts. A key tool to asses this impact is the cost-benefit analysis which is used to determine the net effect of potential revenues and costs.

4 Comment(s)
Case exhibits

Diagram 1


Table 1


The market for special nutrition food in China is rapidly expanding.


Diagram 2


Diagram 3


The Government is shareholder at all 3 of them with different shares.