Shuting down a profitable business to reduce costs

Question

profitability cost reduction

Recent activity on Sep 27, 2017

3 Answers

3.3 k Views

Marie

Proficient

asked on Sep 27, 2017

Looking for experienced partners preparing for top tier firms

Hi all,

In a cost reduction case, a suggestion to reduce costs was to stop manufacturing a specific product. The cost would be lowered by $6000/year, but this specific product segment is still profitable (profit of $1500/year). Saving $6,000/year in costs and suffering a maximum reduction of $1,500/year in profits is deemed to be a net gain of $4,500/year, and therefore a good option.

1. Can cost saving be considered as "profit" ?
2. When does it make sense to shut down a profitable product ? My first assumption is that is does when we know we could use the cost saving to develop a more profitable product.

Any insights on that?

Best

Marie-Eve

Overview of answers

Sort by:

Only show saved answers

Related Cases

Expert case by Ian

Bain + BCG - Hot Wheels WITH VIDEO SOLUTION

Unlock with Premium

Style:

Candidate-led (usual style)

Topics:

Competitive response, Growth strategy, Market analysis, Operations strategy, Profitability analysis Competitive response, Growth strategy

Rating:

4.6

Problem definition: Our client is Korean Car Parts (KCP), a multi-national original equipment manufacturer (OEM) of car parts based in Korea. They've recently seen a decline in profits and have brought us in to understand how to address this falling profitability. Problem definition: Our client is Korean Car Parts (KCP), a multi-national original equipment manufacturer (OEM) of car parts based in Korea. They've recently seen a decline in profits and have brought us in to understand how to address this falling profitability. (Open whole case)

10.7k

Times solved

4.6

300+ Ratings

Intermediate

Difficulty

Expert case by Ian

MBB - Sky China

Unlock with Premium

Style:

Candidate-led (usual style)

Topics:

Capacity change, Competitive response, Growth strategy, Operations strategy, Organizational behavior, Profitability analysis, Public Sector Capacity change, Competitive response

Rating:

4.3

Sky China, a government-backed Chinese airline, has recently seen profits plummet due to COVID-19. Profits are down 80% in the months of February and March, but are showing early signs of a rebound in April. They've brought you in to first investigate what can be done immediatedly to prevent he ... Sky China, a government-backed Chinese airline, has recently seen profits plummet due to COVID-19. Profits are down 80% in the months of February and March, but are showing early signs of a ... (Open whole case)

7.1k

Times solved

4.3

100+ Ratings

Intermediate

Difficulty

Expert case by Ben

Pedal Pals' Financial Fitness Challenge: Cost Optimization Consultancy

Unlock with Premium

Style:

Candidate-led (usual style)

Topics:

Profitability analysis Profitability analysis

Rating:

0.0

Pedal Pals is an interactive fitness platform with millions of members, offering connected, technology-enabled fitness classes that utilize its proprietary hardware, the Pedal Pal stationary bicycle. Pedal Pals generates strong recurring revenue from its members, who pay subscription fees to access ... Pedal Pals is an interactive fitness platform with millions of members, offering connected, technology-enabled fitness classes that utilize its proprietary hardware, the Pedal Pal stationary ... (Open whole case)

< 100

Times solved

0.0

< 100 Ratings

Intermediate

Difficulty

Answer 1

Best answer

Odeh replied on Sep 27, 2017

Hi,

I agree with Anonymous. Costs are not profits but contribute to them. Thus your answer must elaborate on the the difference of profits realised if the product persists or is terminated.

Reasons to shut down a profitable business line:-

1. Cannibalization. This does not need to be for a product in the same category eg. customers stop buying a perfume from a beauty firm because they do animal testing of their make up products

2. There is no competitive advantage and the firm's market share is/will erode quickly in this product segment. Here it may be better to realise the savings and invest the capital in a more profitable area eg. strengthen a dominant position, develop a new product etc

3. The product has a negative effect on the company's brand (intangible effect)

Was this answer helpful?

4

Answer 2

Jonas replied on Sep 27, 2017

Looking for good English or German speaking partners!

1. Cost reductions can not be considered as profit increases as usually they entail revenue reductions as well. In your example, you would simply decrease your costs by 6K, but apparently also decrease your revenue by 7.5K, hence loose 1.5K profit.

2. It makes sense to shut down a profitable product when it cannibanilzes other profit sources or when it binds resources that you could use otherwise to increase profit with a different product.

Was this answer helpful?

1

Answer 3

Anonymous A replied on Sep 27, 2017

Hi, hope this might help.

Always remember that PROFIT = REVENUES - COSTS. Therefore, I wouldn't say that cost saving is considered a profit, but that: "IF THE REDUCTION IN COSTS IS GREATER THAN THE ONE IN REVENUES (considering this scenario in which we are shutting down a product line), THEREBY THE COMPANY WILL INCREASE ITS PROFITS".

Regarding the second question, another idea is shutting down a profitable product because it is cannibalizing others with higher profit margins.

Was this answer helpful?

1

Shuting down a profitable business to reduce costs

Overview of answers

Related Cases

Bain + BCG - Hot Wheels WITH VIDEO SOLUTION

MBB - Sky China

Pedal Pals' Financial Fitness Challenge: Cost Optimization Consultancy

Similar Questions

How to calculate NPV for a cost reduction

Cost Reduction - Structure

In Profitability cases, when analyzing the cost side, how to decide the cost structure breakup?

Similar Questions

How to calculate NPV for a cost reduction

Cost Reduction - Structure

In Profitability cases, when analyzing the cost side, how to decide the cost structure breakup?