Is it a bad idea to tell the same history in first and second round interviews?
Back to overview
12
Same history in first and second round BCG
2
2.6k
Be the first to answer!
Nobody has responded to this question yet.
Top answer
Benjamin
on Oct 12, 2023
Coach
Ex-BCG Principal | 8+ years consulting experience in SEA | BCG top interviewer & top performer
Hi,
When I was at BCG, while it was technically possible that interviews could tell the next interviewer what stories you used, it was very rare that it happened.
So I would say yes you could re-use a story, but always good to have a backup story in case the interviewer doesn't like your current one, or requests for a different context.
0 comments
Vlad
on Mar 04, 2019
Coach
McKinsey / Accenture Alum / Got all BIG3 offers / Harvard Business School
Hi,
It's totally fine to answer with the same story. However, I recommend you having a backup story anyway. The interviewer can say smth like: "This story does not fit. Do you have another one?"
Best
Similar Questions
Most Popular Posts
LEK Numerical reasoning test (Zoom)
12
on Nov 08, 2025
UK
3
200+
Top answer by
Evelina
Coach
EY-Parthenon l Coached 300+ candidates into MBB & Tier-2 l 10% off first session l LBS graduate l Free intro call
3 Answers
200+ Views
Applying to McKinsey Riyadh as a non-Saudi (Norwegian citizen, fluent Arabic): Visa logistics and in-person interview requirements?
11
on Nov 09, 2025
Middle East
5
100+
Top answer by
Sherif
Coach
Ex Sr. Engagement Manager with McKinsey - Aug 25 - Top EEMA interviewer 2023 - 2024 with +350 interviews
5 Answers
100+ Views
+2
What to do after R2 rejection
9
on Nov 09, 2025
USA
6
100+
Top answer by
Evelina
Coach
EY-Parthenon l Coached 300+ candidates into MBB & Tier-2 l 10% off first session l LBS graduate l Free intro call
6 Answers
100+ Views
+3
Did I actually “fail” the McKinsey recruiter screen, or is this normal for experienced hire?
12
on Nov 13, 2025
Global
7
100+
Top answer by
Kevin
Coach
Ex-Bain (London) | Private Equity & M&A | 12+ Yrs Experience | The Reflex Method | Free Intro Call
7 Answers
100+ Views
+4
Is it okay to follow up after an early rejection?
11
on Nov 13, 2025
Middle East
7
100+
Top answer by
Annika
Coach
30% off first session | Bain | MBB Coach | ICF Coach | HEC Paris MBA | 13+ years experience
7 Answers
100+ Views
+4