Back to overview

Top tier 2 firm

Hello,

I have a 15-minute HR screening call with a top Tier-2 strategy consulting firm. I come from a Big 4 non-strategy consulting background and recently left my firm for personal reasons. However, my CV still indicates that I am employed there, which makes me somewhat concerned about how to handle the topic if it comes up during the discussion. For context, I already passed the HR screening with this firm about three years ago as a fresh graduate, although I did not ultimately interview with them due to lack of readiness.

The recruiter mentioned that we would discuss my “motivation for consulting” and  "motivation about the firm“ and align on my positioning within the teams.” Given the short format of the call, what should I expect HR to focus on? How should I position myself coming from a non-strategy background, explain my motivation to move into strategy consulting, and address my employment status if asked?

Part of my dilemma is that I do not want to lie, as it is not aligned with my values. At the same time, I already submitted my CV showing that I am still employed. Several people in France have told me that background checks are often limited, and I recently spoke with an HR expert from a government-backed employment organization who told me that, on paper, a company would not necessarily know unless they specifically contacted my former employer. Knowing that there is a realistic chance I could be invited into the interview process if this call goes well, I feel somewhat lost about the best way to handle the situation. Would you recommend proactively clarifying it, waiting until asked, or taking another approach?

Thank you !

1
< 100
0
Be the first to answer!
Nobody has responded to this question yet.
Profile picture of Mauro
Mauro
Coach
17 min ago
Ex Bain AP | +200 interviews | 15years experience | Top MBB coach

For a 15-minute HR screening, I wouldn't expect anything particularly technical. The recruiter is usually trying to understand three things: why strategy consulting, why this firm, and whether your profile makes sense for the role.
Coming from a Big 4 non-strategy background, I wouldn't position the move as an escape from your current field. Rather, I'd explain that your experience gave you exposure to transformation and implementation work, but that you realized you're most interested in the strategic questions behind those projects: growth, market positioning, performance improvement, investment decisions, etc.
Regarding the employment status, my recommendation is simple: don't volunteer information that wasn't asked, but don't lie if it comes up.
The issue is not whether a background check will find out. The issue is credibility. If they ask whether you're currently employed or about your availability, I'd answer honestly and explain that you left for personal reasons. Most recruiters won't care nearly as much about the fact that the CV wasn't updated as they will about how you explain the transition.
If I were preparing for the call, I'd spend my time refining:
- a strong answer to "Why strategy consulting?"
- a strong answer to "Why our firm?"
- a concise and confident explanation of why you left your previous employer
Those three topics are much more likely to determine the outcome of the conversation than the employment-status question itself.