Is it a bad idea to tell the same history in first and second round interviews?
Back to overview
14
Same history in first and second round BCG
2
3.2k
Top answer
Benjamin
on Oct 12, 2023
Coach
Ex-BCG Principal | 8+ years consulting experience in SEA | BCG top interviewer & top performer
Hi,
When I was at BCG, while it was technically possible that interviews could tell the next interviewer what stories you used, it was very rare that it happened.
So I would say yes you could re-use a story, but always good to have a backup story in case the interviewer doesn't like your current one, or requests for a different context.
0 comments
Want to learn more about this topic or join the discussion?
Sign up for free with PrepLounge and get access to first-hand insights from consulting experts, practical resources for your consulting interview preparation and an international community of candidates. Join the world’s largest case interview community.
McKinsey / Accenture Alum / Got all BIG3 offers / Harvard Business School
Hi,
It's totally fine to answer with the same story. However, I recommend you having a backup story anyway. The interviewer can say smth like: "This story does not fit. Do you have another one?"
Best
Similar Questions
Most Popular Posts
Chances of Roland Berger Return Offer & How to prepare for internship
16
on Nov 6, 2026
DACH
8
200+
Top answer by
Ian
Coach
Ex-BCG | NYU Stern | MBB, Tech, & Strategy Coach | 5,000+ Sessions | 500+ Offers | 1,000+ Candidates | 100+ Countries
8 Answers
200+ Views
+5
EY Vienna - Case Study Digital Transformation
13
on Nov 6, 2026
DACH
6
200+
Top answer by
Carlos
Coach
Free 15 min intro | Engagement manager | 5+ yrs interviewing candidates | 90%+ success rate
6 Answers
200+ Views
+3
All the basics are there, but I still struggle to actually solve the case
20
on Nov 8, 2026
Global
8
200+
Top answer by
Andrzej
Coach
Strategy&, PwC | Middle East, EMEA, CEE
8 Answers
200+ Views
+5
How can I get better at market sizing questions in consulting interviews?
13
on Nov 9, 2026
Global
10
200+
Top answer by
Carlos
Coach
Free 15 min intro | Engagement manager | 5+ yrs interviewing candidates | 90%+ success rate
10 Answers
200+ Views
+7
BCG: Negotiate to get Consultant position
13
on Nov 11, 2026
Middle East
10
100+
Top answer by
Carlos
Coach
Free 15 min intro | Engagement manager | 5+ yrs interviewing candidates | 90%+ success rate
10 Answers
100+ Views
+7