Hi everyone! I was just wondering, as a recent graduate who finished school this past May, if it would be okay to use a PEI story from 2.5 to 3 years ago, if I believe it is my most compelling example for that specific dimension?
Thank you!
McKinsey PEI: Recency threshold for a recent graduate
Hi! Absolutely fine! :) As a recent graduate, nobody expects you to have years of professional experience. What matters most in McKinsey's PEI is the quality of your story, your personal contribution and the impact you made, rather than when it happened. If your example from 2–3 years ago is your strongest one, I'd definitely use it. Just make sure you can explain it in detail and reflect on what you learned. Good luck!
Hi,
Stories from 2.5 to 3 years ago are fine as long as they are genuinely your strongest example for that dimension; as a recent graduate most of your material comes from your university years anyway.
Best,
Franco
This depends entirely on you.
Let me exemplify with an anecdote...
When I interviewed with McKinsey, I had a story in my backpocket that I wanted to tell desperately. So when asked about dimension X, I said to the interviewer something along the lines of:
"There's a story that shows better than any other experience who I am in that regard, and although dates back 7 years, I remember ievery details vividly due to the impact this had on myself and others"
How could an interviewer say no at this point? I told the story and got the job. It's down to you to manage the situation and not leave it all to chance.
For your preparation, consider this guide, which includes everything you need to know about McKinsey's PEI and will help you walk into the interview confidently, knowing what you're doing:
McKinsey PEI Guide: Build Winning Interview Stories | PrepLounge
Yes, I would use it. Two and a half to three years ago puts it in the middle of your degree, which is well within what interviewers expect from someone who graduated in May. Age only starts to look odd when every story is old and suggests nothing has happened since.
The real test is detail. A PEI interviewer goes deep on one story and asks what you said, what you were thinking and what you'd do differently now. If you can still recall those moments clearly, the date is a non-issue. If you find yourself filling gaps, a slightly less impressive but fresher story may hold up better under that probing.
I'd also keep a more recent example ready for the same dimension, in case the interviewer asks for a second one.
Hi there,
There is certainly no points off for a story being 2.5-3 years old. I would absolutely proceed with it!
Hi!
Yes. Typically if you stay within the last 3 years it's perfectly fine. The more recent the better. The idea is to give a sense of who you are at the moment, not who you were a decade ago - thus the recency point.
If you need any help with preparing the PEIs, do reach out.
Best,
Cristian
Hey there :)
Absolutely! If it's your strongest example, use it. McKinsey doesn't have a strict recency cut off for PEI stories. What matters is that you can clearly explain your personal contribution, the challenges you faced and the impact you achieved. Just make sure you still remember the details well enough to answer follow up questions. A strong story from three years ago is much better than a recent but weaker example.
Best, Alessa :)