Hi there!
Yes, absolutely! You can reuse your PEI stories, especially if they remain your strongest examples. There is no expectation that you need to come up with entirely new experiences simply because you're interviewing again.
One thing I'd recommend, though, is revisiting how you tell those stories. I've worked with candidates who initially struggled with PEI despite having very strong experiences. Often, the issue wasn't the story itself, but how they communicated it. For example, one candidate had a great leadership example but spent most of the time describing what the team achieved rather than the specific decisions they made and the challenges they personally overcame. Once we shifted the focus, the same story became much more compelling.
I'd also reflect on what has changed since your last interview. You may have gained new experiences or developed a different perspective on your previous ones, which can make your answers even stronger.
Ultimately, it's not about having a new story, but about telling the strongest story in the most effective way.
Best of luck with your reapplication!