Solution of this case says to reduce the pricing and then admits that this will lower the margin but gain the market share. however, one of the goals of this gase is to increase margin and the share not one or the other I believe.
Schedule mock interviews on the Meeting Board, join the latest community discussions in our Consulting Q&A and find like-minded Interview Partners to connect and practice with!
Back to overview
18
If factories are operating at full capacity (quantity produced can't be increased without significant investments), shouldn't price reductions lead to both decreasing revenues (same quantity x lower prices) and lower profit margins? In that case, the proposed solution doesn't solve any of the objectives of the case, since we know that the Argentinian market is growing by 10%, right?
I think the argument makes sense as the maximum capacity has been reached. Reducing price will not cause increasing units sold due to the shortage of supply unless we open new manufacturing plants, which requires another amount of up-front cost.

Anonymous A
on Jul 25, 2019
Global
Question about
Case
Case solution does not solve the objective of the case
1
4.5k

Be the first to answer!
Nobody has responded to this question yet.
Top answer

Luca
on Dec 23, 2019
Coach
BCG |NASA | SDA Bocconi & Cattolica partner | GMAT expert 780/800 score | 200+ students coached
Hi,
You are right, but it's not always possible to find a solution that satisfies every client's request.
In this case, after your analyses, the interviewer can ask you to present your findings: that lowering price will make our client to gain market share.
Usually the interviewer will then ask you to quickly brainstorm possible alternatives/solution to also increase the margins.
Hope it helps,
Luca
2 comments
K
Kasper
on Oct 21, 2020

Jay
on Jan 09, 2022
Similar Questions
Most Popular Posts
How flexible is the start date for MBB? I initially mentioned that I’m available from November, but I’m now thinking December would be a better fit. I haven’t signed the offer yet.
21
on Sep 21, 2025
Global
9
400+

Top answer by
Thor
Coach
50% discount in September | Ex‑McKinsey EM | 8+ years experience | 100+ Interviewer Sessions | 50+ Candidates Coached
9 Answers
400+ Views


+6
Hello, I'm struggling with the PEI questions. I don't really know which experiences to mention and which ones are most suitable.
19
on Sep 21, 2025
Europe
6
200+

Top answer by
Kevin
Coach
Ex-Bain (London) | Private Equity & M&A | 8+ Yrs Coaching | The Reflex Method | Free Intro Call + 30% Off First Session
6 Answers
200+ Views


+3
How to find MBB application deadlines for graduate roles in the Middle East?
19
on Sep 22, 2025
Middle East
6
200+

Top answer by
Giulia
Coach
3+ years BCG consultant | ex- EY-Parthenon | 50+ case interviews | Free intro call | HEC Paris
6 Answers
200+ Views
S

+3
Would a story about adapting to a new environment be appropriate for the Mckinsey Growth PEI
19
on Sep 24, 2025
Africa
6
200+

Top answer by
Pedro
Coach
Most Senior Coach @ Preplounge: Bain | EY-Parthenon | RB | Principal level interviewer | PEI Expert | 30% in October
6 Answers
200+ Views


+3
Does rejection from the McKinsey and Company case workshop hinder my ability to apply for the open roles in London, and will I be subject to the 12-month waiting period?
18
on Sep 25, 2025
UK
5
400+

Top answer by
Abhinav
Coach
Ex-BCG Consultant and a seasoned consulting coach, helping candidates from landing offer and beyond
5 Answers
400+ Views


+2