Solution of this case says to reduce the pricing and then admits that this will lower the margin but gain the market share. however, one of the goals of this gase is to increase margin and the share not one or the other I believe.
Back to overview
20
If factories are operating at full capacity (quantity produced can't be increased without significant investments), shouldn't price reductions lead to both decreasing revenues (same quantity x lower prices) and lower profit margins? In that case, the proposed solution doesn't solve any of the objectives of the case, since we know that the Argentinian market is growing by 10%, right?
I think the argument makes sense as the maximum capacity has been reached. Reducing price will not cause increasing units sold due to the shortage of supply unless we open new manufacturing plants, which requires another amount of up-front cost.
Anonymous A
on Jul 25, 2019
Global
Question about
Case
Case solution does not solve the objective of the case
1
4.6k
Be the first to answer!
Nobody has responded to this question yet.
Top answer
Luca
on Dec 23, 2019
Coach
BCG |NASA | SDA Bocconi & Cattolica partner | GMAT expert 780/800 score | 200+ students coached
Hi,
You are right, but it's not always possible to find a solution that satisfies every client's request.
In this case, after your analyses, the interviewer can ask you to present your findings: that lowering price will make our client to gain market share.
Usually the interviewer will then ask you to quickly brainstorm possible alternatives/solution to also increase the margins.
Hope it helps,
Luca
2 comments
K
Kasper
on Oct 21, 2020
Jay
on Jan 09, 2022
Similar Questions
Most Popular Posts
BCG Application Status - Under Review for 2 weeks.
11
on Oct 31, 2025
UK
4
200+
Top answer by
Thor
Coach
1st session 50% off | Ex‑McKinsey EM | 8+ years experience | 100+ Interviewer Sessions | 50+ Candidates Coached
4 Answers
200+ Views
+1
MBB U.S Exit Opportunities to work Internationally in Dubai/Gulf Region
7
on Nov 02, 2025
Middle East
3
100+
Top answer by
Kevin
Coach
Ex-Bain (London) | Private Equity & M&A | 12+ Yrs Experience | The Reflex Method | Free Intro Call
3 Answers
100+ Views
Application status closed 3 days after first-round interview at McKinsey but no email notice
7
on Nov 03, 2025
Asia
5
100+
Top answer by
Alessa
Coach
MBB Expert | Ex-McKinsey | Ex-BCG | Ex-Roland Berger
5 Answers
100+ Views
+2
What are the different approaches to cases depending on the firms?
7
on Nov 03, 2025
Global
6
200+
Top answer by
Hafeezah
Coach
1st session -50% | Ex-McKinsey, Ex-Coca-Cola Strategy |Offical McKinsey Case Coach | +250 coaching sessions
6 Answers
200+ Views
+3
BCG 2nd Round - Real Life Interview
9
on Nov 03, 2025
DACH
3
100+
Top answer by
Colin
Coach
Ex-BCG Project Leader in Zurich & Atlanta | Experienced interviewer for intern and full-time Swiss & US hiring
3 Answers
100+ Views