Verabrede dich zum Casen über das Meeting-Board, nimm an Diskussionen in unserem Consulting Q&A teil und finde gleichgesinnte Interview-Partner:innen, um dich auszutauschen und gemeinsam zu üben!
Zurück zur Übersicht

One VP says I’m doing well, but another told me I need to step up. How should I handle the mixed feedback during my IB internship?

5
500+
17
Schreibe die erste Antwort!
Bisher hat niemand auf diese Frage reagiert.
Beste Antwort
Rita
Coach
am 23. Apr. 2025
Excel in Finance | FREE 15 Minutes Intro Call | Personalised Preparation

Hey,
Getting mixed feedback during an IB internship is completely normal. Different VPs tend to value different things, so it's not unusual at all.

Rather than comparing what each VP said, I’d suggest following up directly with the one who told you to step up. Ask in a calm and open way if they can clarify what areas they think you should focus on. For example:
"Thanks for the feedback. I really want to improve. Are there specific areas where you'd like to see more from me?"

It’s best not to bring up that someone else said you’re doing well, that can come across as defensive. And even when things are going well, there’s always room to grow. That’s exactly what internships are for.

Asking for specifics and showing you're eager to learn makes a strong impression. It signals maturity and coachability, which matter just as much as technical skills.

You're already on the right track by taking the feedback seriously.

Rita

Simon
Coach
am 24. Apr. 2025
Mastering Deals and Strategy | Seasoned coach

Great that you’re getting feedback! That’s actually a sign people are invested in your growth.

In IB, part of the challenge isn’t just doing good work, it’s learning how to manage multiple stakeholders with different expectations. So if one VP says you’re doing well and another wants more, see that as a chance to calibrate and adapt your style.

I’d recommend treating the “step up” comment as a prompt to clarify what they specifically care about (speed? attention to detail? initiative?) and then try to incorporate that without neglecting what’s already working.

Ultimately, being able to take varied feedback and adjust on the fly is exactly what analysts need to succeed. If you approach it that way, you’ll stand out.

Natalie
Coach
am 25. Apr. 2025
Ex-Investment Banker | Former Deloitte & Grant Thornton | Coaching Finance Candidates to Ace Interviews & Land Top Roles

Oh, that's a tough spot to be in during your internship! It's definitely not uncommon to get different feedback from different people, but it can feel confusing and a bit disheartening.
My advice would be to chat with each of them separately. For the one who said you're doing well, try to get specific examples of what you nailed. That helps you know what to keep doing. Then, with the other VP, ask for really clear, concrete examples of what they'd like to see you improve. Don't be afraid to ask for suggestions on how to "step up."Understanding both perspectives will help you figure out how to navigate things. It's all part of learning the ropes! What kind of feedback did they give you specifically?

Nitesh
Coach
am 24. Mai 2025
9+ yrs of work ex in finance/consulting - Barclays/ x-Citi. 500+ hrs coaching exp. MBA IIM Ahmedabad, Engg IIT Kharagpur

Hi,

Getting mixed feedback like that can definitely feel confusing, but it’s also a chance to grow. I’d recommend taking both perspectives seriously without letting either define you entirely. Try to understand specifically what the VP who said you need to “step up” means are there particular skills or behaviors they expect more of? It might help to have a candid conversation with them to clarify expectations and ask for actionable advice.

At the same time, recognize what you’re doing well from the other VP’s feedback and keep building on those strengths. Balancing both views shows you’re open to learning and adaptable, which is exactly what IB teams value. Ultimately, using the feedback as fuel to improve rather than letting it discourage you will help you make the most of your internship experience.

Binika
Coach
am 21. Juni 2025
9+ years in Finance, Consulting and Strategy, Corporate Development|Accenture| Coach Finance Candidates to Ace Interview

Hi There!

Mixed feedback during an investment banking internship is more common than it seems, and it’s important to approach it with maturity and curiosity rather than frustration. Start by reflecting on the specific feedback you received — what the VP who asked you to “step up” might have seen differently. Were there moments where you could have been more proactive, more detail-oriented, or quicker to follow up? Use that as a chance to course-correct and show responsiveness.

At the same time, don’t ignore the positive feedback either. It’s a good sign that at least one senior is noticing your strengths. Consider asking both VPs for quick check-ins. Thank them for their feedback, and ask for specific examples so you know exactly how to improve. This shows professionalism, self-awareness, and willingness to grow — qualities that often matter just as much as technical performance. Balancing different expectations is part of the job, and the way you respond will leave a lasting impression.

Ähnliche Fragen
Finance
How can I get a internship in investment banking with no experience?
am 3. Sept. 2024
Global
7
5,5k
111
7 Antworten
5,5k Aufrufe
Finance
How do you prepare for an investment banking interview as a beginner?
am 6. Okt. 2024
Global
3
1,6k
50
3 Antworten
1,6k Aufrufe
Finance
Working hours in IB vs consulting?
am 23. Okt. 2024
Global
5
2,6k
68
5 Antworten
2,6k Aufrufe
Finance
IB to Consulting or Consulting to IB - What's easier?
am 24. Okt. 2024
Global
3
1,5k
59
3 Antworten
1,5k Aufrufe
Finance
Is it possible to break into investment banking with a liberal arts background?
am 29. Okt. 2024
Global
3
1,1k
30
3 Antworten
1,1k Aufrufe
Mehr anzeigen