How to deal with a counsel to leave?

Hi Anonymous,

I'm not sure I agree with your basic premise that "this experience is inevitable for a majority of consultants". Actually, from my 7 years ant McKinsey and BCG, I experienced that only a relatively small fraction of the consultants who leave are actually forced to do so. The yearly attrition rate is roughly 20%, and clearly less than half of these would be "counseled to leave". Assuming that about 1/3 of leaving consultants are forced to do so would mean that the yearly "CTL-rate" stands at about 6.7%. With an average emploayment duration of about 4 years for MBB consultants, this would mean that the statistical probability of getting counseled out at some point in your career is 25-30%. Clearly not a majority! :)

That being said - of course it is a blow if it happens! What helps is to always remind yourself that your worth as an individual AND ALSO AS A PROFESSIONAL is not tied to becoming a partner at MBB. A substantial part of people who leave MBB become much more successful in the long run than their counterparts who remain on the consulting track! MBB consulting is just one path out of many possibilities.

Cheers, Sidi

(edited)

I am not an expert nor have I worked at any MBB. I hope you don't mind me sharing a valuable content I stumbled on with respect to your question. I hope it helps.
Counselled To Leave Mckinsey. What Should I do? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q-TPr8zi2ow

Hi,

I would disagree with the numbers provided by the other coaches since 4 years seems too high. The average is around 2.5-3

But consulting is not the best job in the world and you just need to get more information about the opportunities / career paths around you.

Best!

Mathematically, I agree with Sidi and Elias that fewer than half are probably counseled out. Remember though that even Principals and Partners are 'kicked out' when they miss the election window => you are in good company :)

How to deal with it? Remember your experience was unique, you have learned a ton, and you will be an alumnus your whole life with all the benefits that come with it (reputation, network, even access to career services). Years after I left, my boss still introduced me as "ex-BCG". People don't care why you left, they mostly just care that you were good enough to get in. And yes, a number of us end up doing just as well outside of MBB as we would have done inside - even if our salary may not always have kept up.

Still feeling down & hurt? just look back to your 'before' and ask yourself if you'd have been happy at the time with the experience you have today (or the salary for that matter).

Agree 100% with Sidi.

Yes, this is a blow at first, but think of the fable of the farmer whose horse ran away.

https://medium.com/@davidgallan/who-knows-what-s-good-or-bad-my-tedx-talk-transcript-8404344779ce

(edited)