Hi everyone,
Apologies in advance for the long post, and thank you to anyone who takes the time to read through it. I have quite an unconventional background and several questions, so I wanted to provide enough context for the advice to be meaningful.
---
I would really appreciate some candid advice from former MBB consultants, recruiters, or coaches, particularly those with experience recruiting in Southeast Asia.
I am trying to understand what the most realistic path would be for someone with my background to eventually break into MBB consulting.
My background is quite unconventional.
I completed my undergraduate degree in Business Management with a focus on Entrepreneurship at a UK university, followed several years later by a master's degree in a finance-related field from a well-regarded university in Singapore.
My professional career has not followed the traditional consulting / corporate route.
I initially worked in business development and education in Singapore, followed by several years in financial services and wealth management, including advising individual clients and working on cross-border investment involving Indonesia and Singapore. This is before my Master Degree.
For the past 6 years, after completing my Master, however, I have primarily been an entrepreneur / operator.
I have been involved in building and operating several owner-operated businesses across e-commerce, consumer distribution, and F&B.
The most substantial was a consumer e-commerce business that I helped build from a very small initial capital base to around 10x in monthly net profit in comparison with the initial capital during its strongest period.
My involvement covered market research and entry, commercial strategy, pricing, financial modelling, unit economics, marketing, supplier management, inventory, operations, and team management.
I have also been involved in developing a consumer distribution business in Indonesia, including market-entry strategy, retail and marketplace strategy, pricing, partnerships, and developing a network of reseller/distribution partners.
So although my current CV describes some of this experience as an “Independent Business Strategy Consultant,” I want to be very clear that I do not have a traditional consulting background.
Most of this experience came from actually building and operating businesses that I was involved in, rather than serving multiple external consulting clients.
I am now trying to transition into a more structured professional career, with a long-term goal of becoming a management consultant, ideally at MBB.
My main questions are:
1. How much value does entrepreneurial experience like this actually have in MBB recruiting?
I have genuine experience with market entry, commercial strategy, financial modelling, pricing, unit economics, growth, partnerships, and solving operational/business problems.
But I don't know how much of that translates into evidence of consulting potential from an MBB recruiter's perspective.
Would this be viewed as meaningful relevant experience, or would I essentially still be treated as someone without traditional consulting experience?
I would particularly appreciate an honest answer here. I don't want to overestimate the value of my entrepreneurial background.
2. What would be the most realistic bridge into MBB?
Would it make more sense to:
- apply directly for Associate / Consultant positions;
- join a smaller strategy consulting firm first and try to lateral into MBB;
- target Big 4 / strategy boutiques;
- move into corporate strategy / business development first;
- pursue an internship despite having several years of professional experience;
- or take another route?
I'd be particularly interested in hearing from people who have seen genuinely unconventional candidates make this transition.
3. Would doing another MBA actually help?
I already have both an undergraduate degree and a master's degree from reputable institutions, including a master's from a well-regarded university in Singapore.
However, I am wondering whether an MBA could help me reset my profile and gain access to structured consulting recruitment.
The specific question is whether doing an MBA at a non-target or less-targeted university in Indonesia would actually improve my chances meaningfully, or whether it would simply cost me 1–2 years without giving me the recruiting access I need. (Because apparently there are no target school for MBA in Indonesia, as far as I'm aware). And I am unable to travel out of Indonesia for years at a time.
Would an MBA from a non-target school realistically help someone with my background break into MBB?
And would it make sense to effectively restart through MBA internship / associate recruiting, despite already having several years of professional experience?
4. How much of a disadvantage is my non-linear career history?
I have spent significant time building businesses rather than progressing through a conventional corporate hierarchy.
On one hand, I think this has given me quite a lot of exposure to real SME business problems.
On the other hand, I don't have the typical profile of someone who went through the traditional analyst → consulting / banking / corporate strategy → MBA → MBB route.
So I'm trying to understand how recruiters would actually interpret my profile.
One other concern: case interview speed
There is also a personal concern I'd appreciate honest feedback on.
I don't think I have a fundamental problem understanding case interviews. I can generally work through the logic, calculations, and business reasoning.
My issue is speed.
For example, I took an MBB online assessment previously. During the test, I believe that I get the right answer, but sometimes I get there slightly too slowly for the time constraint.
I've been outside a structured academic / analytical environment for quite some time, and I sometimes feel that my processing speed under time pressure is not where it needs/used to be.
For people who have coached candidates: how much can this realistically be improved through deliberate practice?
Is this primarily a trainable case-interview skill, or would you see it as a more fundamental concern for someone targeting MBB?
Finally, if you were in my position...
Given the combination of:
- entrepreneurial / operating experience;
- financial services experience;
- market-entry and commercial strategy experience;
- a master's degree from a target Singapore university;
- several years outside the conventional consulting pipeline;
- and limited traditional consulting experience,
what path would you actually pursue if the long-term goal were MBB?
I'm not looking for encouragement or a generic “anything is possible” answer.
I'd genuinely appreciate a realistic assessment of:
- how MBB recruiters are likely to view this profile;
- whether the entrepreneurial experience is genuinely valuable or mostly irrelevant to recruiting;
- whether I should apply directly or build a bridge first;
- whether another MBA makes sense;
- whether starting through an internship would be realistic; and
- what I should focus on over the next 1–3 years.
Thanks in advance. I'm particularly interested in hearing from former MBB consultants, recruiters, or coaches who have dealt with unconventional candidates.
Ps. The businesses I currently run has 1) being taken over, 2) reached its maturity point and can be treated as a source of passive income. I do not see myself growing the businesses much more, due to limited source of capital.
