Schedule mock interviews on the Meeting Board, join the latest community discussions in our Consulting Q&A and find like-minded Interview Partners to connect and practice with!
Back to overview

Too structured in Brainstorming

Hi everyone, just passed to the final round at McKinsey! The feedback from HR was that I was too structured in brainstorming! Any tips?

6
600+
26
Be the first to answer!
Nobody has responded to this question yet.
Top answer
Michael
Coach
on Jul 09, 2024
Ex-McKinsey EM | I help aspiring consultants from atypical background to nail case interviews

First of all, congratuations!

As other experts suggested, it's necessary to clarify what exactly “too structured” means in the feedback.

The brainstorming part is to see a candidate coming up with sufficient sensible answers / hypothesis / explanations / ideas / etc., and ideally there would be something innovative. It does not require a structure to do so, but a certain structure helps you communicate your answers clearly with the interviewer.

Good practices I see from experts as well as from strong candidates:

  • A top-down approach (structured brainstorming), refer to this article “Breakthrough Thinking from Inside the Box” from HBR. If you happened to use this approach, there are potential risks of: 1) spending too much time, 2) laying out the entire structure when communicating your answer. The solution is to do it mentally, and give the answer in a simpler structure.
  • Bottom-up approach, more often used by people for whom coming up a lot of ideas is easy. Then just “structure” the laundry list first before sharing back, but don't over do the structure, 1 level should suffice.
Anonymous B
on Jul 03, 2024

Thank you for producing such a fascinating essay on this subject. This has sparked a lot of thought in me, and I'm looking forward to reading more. Thank you for producing such a fascinating essay on this subject. This has sparked a lot of thought in me, and I'm looking forward to reading more my web site 

13
Alessa
Coach
on Jul 03, 2024
xMcKinsey & Company | xBCG | +200 individual & group coachings | feel free to schedule a 15 min intro call for free

Hey, congrats first of all! 

I could imagine that you used frameworks to create your brainstorming structure. I would ensure that the brainstorming section does not include any frameworks - keep them in mind when thinking about drivers but do not use the framework itself as a driver (e.g., customer, company, competitors). 

BR, 

Alessa 

Florian
Coach
on Jul 03, 2024
1400 5-star reviews across platforms | 600+ offers | Highest-rated case book on Amazon | Uni lecturer in US, Asia, EU

Hi there,

That's a bit of an odd feedback to receive. 

Would you mind sharing the question and answer to understand this a bit better (feel free to DM if you want to stay private).

Cheers,

Florian

Pedro
Coach
on Jul 03, 2024
Bain | EY-Parthenon | Former Principal | 1.5h session | 30% discount 1st session

Feels like you created a full scale structure to answer a simple question… There should be some structure on these qualitative questions, but the answer cannot be about the structure.

Hagen
Coach
on Sep 06, 2024
#1 recommended coach | >95% success rate | 8+ years consulting, 8+ years coaching and 7+ years interviewing experience

Hi there,

First of all, congratulations on the progress in the application process with McKinsey thus far!

I would be happy to share my thoughts on your question:

  • First of all, if possible, I would highly advise you to clarify what the feedback was really about if you don't seem to understand it.
  • Moreover, from an outside perspective, it sounds like you overdid it with the structuring in this qualitative question. In these questions, the most important criterion is creativity, not structure, even if it has to be structured. Therefore, try to shift your focus slightly in order to be successful in the final interview round.

You can find more on this topic here: How to succeed in the final interview round.

If you would like a more detailed discussion on how to best prepare for your upcoming McKinsey final-round interviews, please don't hesitate to contact me directly.

Best,

Hagen

Similar Questions
Consulting
Prep Materials for Mckinsey Solve Assessment
on May 24, 2025
Global
6
1.8k
Top answer by
Evelina
Coach
EY-Parthenon (6 years) l BCG offer holder l 97% success rate l 30% off first session l free 15' intro call l LBS
50
6 Answers
1.8k Views
+3
Consulting
McKinsey PEI
on Apr 02, 2025
Global
7
2.6k
Top answer by
Deleted user
58
7 Answers
2.6k Views
+4
Consulting
Preparing for McKinsey PEI
on Jul 10, 2024
Global
7
5.1k
Top answer by
Nilay
Coach
Former McKinsey Sr Engagement Manager | Trained McKinsey interviewer (100+ interviews, 500+ coaching sessions)
116
7 Answers
5.1k Views
+4