Schedule mock interviews on the Meeting Board, join the latest community discussions in our Consulting Q&A and find like-minded Interview Partners to connect and practice with!
Back to overview
Anonymous A
on Oct 06, 2019
Global

Tell me about a time you had to make a recommendation without having all the facts.

How would you answer this question in your Personal Fit interview? Receive feedback on your answer and browse through the Q&As to review the approaches of other applicants and experts.

11
4.3k
25
Be the first to answer!
Nobody has responded to this question yet.
Top answer
on Jan 04, 2024

Eine Beziehungssituation, bei der ich die andere Person nicht kannte und nur die Infos aus Sicht der ersten, involvierten Person hatte

7
Anonymous G
on Jan 28, 2024

In einer privaten Situation

7
Anonymous H
on Jul 28, 2025

As part of one of my classes, I had to make an initial recommendation for a company that wants to enter on the international market. We don´t have a lot of information about the company, the industry, or the specific country in which they could enter. I have decided to make a recommendation of a possible country to consider based on certain characteristics like the growth of the country, the size of the market, and the possibilities of the company to move its supply chain to another country. 

4
Anonymous D
on Aug 03, 2022

Last year, some professors and I started to design a new study program. I had to do plenty of feasibility studies. Still, in the short time from creating this plan to the first decision on whether or not to continue, it was impossible to acquire all the essential information on legal circumstances and achievable time frames. Still, to make the first recommendation, I evaluated all gathered data and made assumptions about the points not collected yet. I presented my advice to the group and communicated the process of analysis and assumptions.

2
Anonymous E
on Oct 24, 2022

During my research project i need to reach a final conclusion without having all facts due to limited time and resources. To do this I prioritize the most important factors to measure and make reasonable assumptions for the rest of the parameters based on available literature. 

2
Deleted
Coach
on Mar 10, 2020
Consultant at BCG Nordics| PE and Due Diligence | BCG London, Boston & Dubai office experience

This happens far too happen in real consulting that you might think. So this is a very practical question.

In such scenarios, one option could be to triangulate the answer to the best possible extent. Try to think scenario from the past where you worked with a hypothesis and then what could be the secondary sources you could have used to triangulate that hypothesis. 

Anonymous B
on Oct 05, 2020
Anonymous C
on Oct 18, 2021

During an internship, the time constraint prevented us from making an exhaustive analysis, so I applied a test and lear strategy and made assumptions. 

This is how I got a first glimpse into the hypothesis-driven approach.

0
on Dec 14, 2021

During beamtime we had to quickly decide a measurement route for an experiment, although not all parameters were clear. Still, the time is only limited and, hence, fast decisions have to be made. 

0
on Apr 05, 2022
Anonymous F
on Oct 22, 2023

I would keep the recommendation in advantage of the client as good as possible without letting room for any risk or damage.

0
Similar Questions
Consulting
Who do you need as your 'right hand'?
on Sep 18, 2019
Global
14
2.9k
37
14 Answers
2.9k Views
Consulting
What gets you up every day?
on Sep 21, 2019
Global
45
3.1k
43
45 Answers
3.1k Views
Consulting
What are your hobbies?
on Sep 21, 2019
Global
32
5.1k
53
32 Answers
5.1k Views
Consulting
Are you ready for the long working hours you will face as a future consultant?
on Sep 21, 2019
Global
28
3.8k
50
28 Answers
3.8k Views
Consulting
What other firms are you applying for?
on Sep 21, 2019
Global
30
3.7k
50
30 Answers
3.7k Views
Show more