Back to overview

I interviewed on Dec 2024 for Senior Procurement Analyst and got rejected after the final round. The feedback I got was I lost points on problem solving but scored good on PEI, and TEI. I reapplied for the same position now. Do they start the interview process from scratch?

5
< 100
2
Be the first to answer!
Nobody has responded to this question yet.
Top answer
Profile picture of Alessa
Alessa
Coach
on Jan 15, 2026
MBB Expert | Ex-McKinsey | Ex-BCG | Ex-Roland Berger

hey there :)

Usually yes, they restart the process from scratch, with fresh interviews and new scores, although the recruiting team may still see your previous application and feedback in the background, so it helps that you addressed the problem solving gap; feel free to reach out if you have more questions. best, Alessa :)

Profile picture of Benjamin
on Jan 15, 2026
Ex-BCG Principal | 8+ years consulting experience in SEA | BCG top interviewer & top performer

Hi,

Yes, in most instances you will have to go through the same interview process again. 

One of the few exceptions i've seen is sometimes firms waive the first screening online test.

All the best!

Profile picture of Evelina
Evelina
Coach
on Jan 15, 2026
EY-Parthenon l Ex-Deloitte l BCG offer l LBS

Hi there,

Yes, if you’ve reapplied and are being considered again, the interview process typically starts from scratch. Even though your previous feedback is on file, interviewers will reassess you based on your current performance rather than automatically carrying over prior scores.

That said, the bar may be slightly higher the second time around, and interviewers will expect to see clear improvement in the area you previously fell short on, in your case problem solving. Stronger performance there can meaningfully change the outcome.

Best,
Evelina

Profile picture of Jenny
Jenny
Coach
on Jan 16, 2026
Buy 1 get 1 free for 1st time clients | Ex-McKinsey Manager & Interviewer | +7 yrs Coaching | Go from good to great

Hi there,

Yes you will be starting from scratch.

Profile picture of Kevin
Kevin
Coach
4 hrs ago
Ex-Bain (London) | Private Equity & M&A | 12+ Yrs Experience | The Reflex Method | Free Intro Call

Getting cut after the final round is brutal, especially when you have excellent fit scores (PEI/TEI)—you were right on the cusp. Here is the reality of reapplying.

While the interview process itself technically "restarts" (new schedule, new interviewers in some cases, fresh scores), your previous application history and the specific feedback (lost points on problem solving) are immediately visible to the recruiting coordinator and, critically, to the hiring manager for a specialized role like Senior Procurement Analyst. They aren't going to forget that you just went through the full cycle three months ago.

The immediate challenge isn't the interviews themselves, but the initial screening. If you are applying to the exact same role on the exact same team, the assumption will be that you haven't had enough time to demonstrably close a significant analytical gap. To successfully convert this second application, you must preemptively manage that perception.

When you get a call or send a follow-up email, you need to explicitly state: "Since my December final round, I focused intensely on closing the analytical gap identified in the feedback. I've completed X and Y (e.g., specific case training, analytical courses, or relevant work project where you led the quantitative analysis)." You must provide evidence that this time, the problem-solving will be watertight. Don't wait for them to ask; address the prior rejection head-on. That shows self-awareness and urgency.

All the best with the pivot. You got this close once, which means the underlying fit is there.