expert
Expert with best answer

Francesco

100% Recommendation Rate

2,773 Meetings

3,395 Q&A Upvotes

USD 349 / Coaching

3

Should I mention to recruiters that I almost got an offer in one of MBBs?

When applying to other consulting companies (also MBB and 2nd tier) should I mention that I made it to the final round of interviews with one of MBBs? I was told than only a very small fraction of candidates can make it to the last round, so probably not a shame to be rejected.

I am just not sure what recruiters in other consulting companies may think? Will it indicate that I am a strong candidate or rather they will consider me "weak" as I did not get an offer from one of MBBs?

When applying to other consulting companies (also MBB and 2nd tier) should I mention that I made it to the final round of interviews with one of MBBs? I was told than only a very small fraction of candidates can make it to the last round, so probably not a shame to be rejected.

I am just not sure what recruiters in other consulting companies may think? Will it indicate that I am a strong candidate or rather they will consider me "weak" as I did not get an offer from one of MBBs?

3 answers

  • Upvotes
  • Date ascending
  • Date descending
Best Answer
Book a coaching with Francesco

100% Recommendation Rate

2,773 Meetings

3,395 Q&A Upvotes

USD 349 / Coaching

Hi Piotr,

I agree with Vlad, mentioning you reached the final round will probably leave a bad impression, giving the idea you were not a top candidate in that round; I would thus avoid to mention it.

Best,
Francesco

Hi Piotr,

I agree with Vlad, mentioning you reached the final round will probably leave a bad impression, giving the idea you were not a top candidate in that round; I would thus avoid to mention it.

Best,
Francesco

Book a coaching with Vlad

97% Recommendation Rate

377 Meetings

5,885 Q&A Upvotes

USD 189 / Coaching

Hi,

Almost got an offer does not mean anything. On the contrary - if you failed the 2nd round, that means that you are not the strongest candidate.

You should mention another MBB offer only if you actually have it and want to speed up the process.

Best

Hi,

Almost got an offer does not mean anything. On the contrary - if you failed the 2nd round, that means that you are not the strongest candidate.

You should mention another MBB offer only if you actually have it and want to speed up the process.

Best

Book a coaching with Vasilis

100% Recommendation Rate

48 Meetings

49 Q&A Upvotes

USD 269 / Coaching

Hey Piotr,

Almost getting an offer would sound like a rejection to me (well, me back in my recruitment days). As an interviewer, we are generally trained to ignore unnecessary data points and focus on candidate performance only. What happened in another interview is irrelevant, and I would therefore treat it as such.

Albeit cruel, this is the reality.

Best of luck!

Vasilis

Hey Piotr,

Almost getting an offer would sound like a rejection to me (well, me back in my recruitment days). As an interviewer, we are generally trained to ignore unnecessary data points and focus on candidate performance only. What happened in another interview is irrelevant, and I would therefore treat it as such.

Albeit cruel, this is the reality.

Best of luck!

Vasilis