Compared to MBA graduate hires, is "experienced hire" also flexible about industry background or roles? I have graduated from MBA and works in finance (sales & product function, not directly related to strategy). I have noticed that for experienced hires, on the job description consulting firms seems to prefer "candidates with consulting experience". Also, I have talked to a HR at a consulting firm, and he mentioned that he would only hire people with FMCG or automobile background. Do I still have a chance of getting interviews? Thanks for your thoughts!
Get Active in Our Amazing Community of Over 448,000 Peers!
Is experienced hire flexible about industry background?
Overview of answers
-
Upvotes
-
Date ascending
-
Date descending
Hi Anonymous,
Honestly speaking I see chances for an experienced hire without industry background rather small. However, it mainly depends on the search profile of the specific company - you can be both experience in either the industry or the function - or both.
Whenever I have a chance to hire an experienced person, I will try to push as much as possible to get experience both from a functional as well as industry experience.
If I have to choose between the two, I always go for the industry experience which is much more specific; the functional experience is comparably generic and can be coached in-house also rather easily.
Hope that helps!
Robert
Hi there,
Experienced hires are usually hired for their experiences in certain industry practice - either ex-consultants with an industry focus, or people who have been in a particular industry for quite a few years.
As per which industry the firm would hire for, it depends a lot on the firm and the specific region/country the office is in. Some consulting firms might only have strong FMCG or Auto practices in a certain country/region, and that's why they only hire for those. Given that you have been in finance, try to find out whether there is a firm in your country that is strong in serving banks or financial insititions?
Best,
Emily
Hi, It really depends on what level you are starting in the consulting firm. For below manager roles it usually not an issue as long as you have strong achievement and pass the case interview. I had a friend in BCG who was Marketing Manager and started 2 level below Manager and now already a Partner. Another case in BCG is a Sales Director and started 1 level below Manager.
The HR you talked to might be referring to a specific needs for an Expert Role in the firm at that moment. Currently consultin firms also created Expert Career track where they recruit senior people from industry to be SME in specfic projects. In an expert track you will work in one industry / function only and need to do multiple projects at the same time (as your scope is more limited).
Hello!
You have a good combination between MBA + past experience so you should not have any problem to at least start with the recruiting process.
Cheers,
Clara
Hi there,
you can still potentially manage to get an invitation, however you should:
- emphasize strategy experience in your CV, even if your role was not specifically in strategy
- identify companies that work in a field related to your current industry so that you can provide more added value
- find referrals in the company that could help to stand out
Best,
Francesco
Hi,
Experienced hires can have various backgrounds. However, there is a key criteria here - your experience should be relevant to consulting:
- Previous client-service experience (Consulting, IB)
- Relevant industry experience (Depends on the particular office) and industries with universal skillset (like FMCG)
- Relevant functions (Digital, Ops, etc)
- Unique client value prop that you can bring to the plate (e.g. brand strategy)
- Scientific background (PHD), ideally in the relevant industries (e.g. oil&gas) or functions (e.g. predictive maintenance)
- Unique career track with significant achievements (e.g. top-known musician)
Best
Hello,
It is possible to get an interview whatever it is your previous experience, but the practice you will be assignes is strongly influenced by your background.
Best,
Luca
Hi, it depends on the seniority. If you apply for second level positions (e.g. associate in McK or consultant in Bain and BCG) almost every experience is considered acceptable.
Best,
Antonello
Hi A,
The situation when experienced hire could have different background is very rare. The most common situation is when you have finance background, so you will be hired for finance practice; if you have FMSG background, then it would be FMSG practice. So, your previous background should somehow correlate to your future competence center where you would like to work.
Hope it helps!
Best,
André
Related Products
High-Impact Interview Coaching
- Professional Case + Fit Prep
- 100% Risk-Free Coaching
- 10+ Years Coaching Experience
Related Articles
Consulting Career Path
BCG Case Interview
Consulting Industry Trends in 2023
What Is Management Consulting?
MBB Target Schools in the US
PowerPoint for Consultants
Working Hours in Consulting
M&A Consulting
Roland Berger Consulting Case Interviews
Free Guide to OC&C Consulting Case Interviews
Management Consulting Firms in Singapore
Consulting Lingo
Consulting Recruitment
Work-Life-Balance in Consulting – Everything You Need to Know
Coffee Chat Questions in Consulting
Consulting Survival Guide
Excel for Consultants
The Pros and Cons of Working at a Top Consulting Firm
How to Get a Consulting Internship - Tips and Tricks
Start Your Career in Consulting now
Consulting Salary in Australia
Overcome Your Weaknesses with ChatGPT for Your Consulting Career
What Is Sustainability Consulting?
Consulting Salaries in France
Become a Top Consultant: The Consulting Recruiting Process
Well-Known Tier 2 Consulting Companies
The Role of Diversity and Inclusion in Consulting
The Most Interesting Consulting Firms Besides MBB
What is Automotive Consulting?
Consulting Salaries in the DACH Region 2024
Consultant Salaries in Canada
What Is Change Management Consulting?
The Typical Terms in Case Study Interviews for Consulting Firms
What Is Leadership Consulting?
Remote Consulting: The Change in the Work Life of a Consultant
The Resignation Letter in Consulting
Is Doing an MBA or MiM Worth It For a Consulting Career?
10 Rumors About Management Consultants
Restructuring Consulting – What is it?
16 Personalities Test
Mastering Communication Skills in Consulting
Stay informed and navigate the future of consulting with confidence.
KI revolutioniert die Beratung! McKinsey, BCG, Bain und EY gestalten d
Smart Solutions for a Sustainable Tomorrow: AI in Consulting
What Are Decision-Making Frameworks And Why Are They Important?
Consulting Salaries in the United States 2024
Top Consulting Firms in the US - Best Firms to Work for 2024
Related Cases
Related Case Interview Basics article(s)
The Role of the Hypothesis in Consulting
Explore how hypotheses serve as guiding lights in the dynamic world of consulting, leading to innovative solutions and transformative outcomes.
The PESTEL Analysis for Consulting
Unlock the potential of PESTEL analysis to drive success and thrive in the dynamic world of consulting.
The Capability Maturity Model (CMM)
Discover the CMM framework and its extension to the Capability Maturity Model Integration (CMMI), focuses on improving processes within an organization.