It has occured to me that unless sites like Victor Cheng's caseinterview.com and preplounge existed we all (undergraduate candidates) would be woefully unprepared. The company websites mention "practising a few cases" and "thinking about your motivation" a week or so before the interview - yet surely they must know that most candidates spend at least +20h on live practice cases alone. Likewise, it is only from websites like these that I would know that I need to understand how to do DCF, NPV etc in a case. Yet the firms claim that they hire from any discipline (as if knowing what DCF is innate knowledge). Why do firms underplay the extent of business knowledge that is needed?
Werde aktiv in unserer Community aus über 451.000 Gleichgesinnten!
Why aren't MBB (and other firms) upfront about the amount and type of of preparation required to be successful at interview?
Übersicht der Antworten
-
Upvotes
-
Datum aufsteigend
-
Datum absteigend
A number of comments here:
1) Firms underplay it because they don't want candidates that will be good at interviews as a result of countless hours of practice - they want candidates that demonstrate the key skills/qualities that consulting firms look for. To demonstrate the core of these, 5-10 hours of proper practice was typically seen as enough. Firms don't want to miss out on potential strong candidates just because they were not aware about consulting 6 months before interviewing and could dedicate countless hours to prep - so major firms at target schools often have case-workshops to try and limit this bias.
2) In a way, it is due to sites like Victor Cheng and PrepLounge that has led to the requirement for most people to do many more hours of practice. As everyone has access to more and better material, the average quality of interviews increases - so firms have to be more selective, and the "passing criteria" have become more and more demanding.
3) Finally, on your point about DCF - I think this is a huge misconception. If you are applying from undergrad or from a non-business background, you will not be expected to understand DCF, NPV, etc. Part of the reason people think this is expected is because most case resources come from business school (MBA) case books - where students learn these topics, and see firms might choose to test them on their knowledge. However, I can guarantee that if you are applying to MBB out of undergrad, you will never be expected to know these technical terms/methods, or be penalised for not knowing them. The only exception might be if you are applying to a very specific role within a company (e.g. M&A advisory) where e.g. NPV might be particularly important.
Hope this clarifies some of your questions.
Honest answer: Because if you're not able to find that out on your own, you're probably not cut out to be a successful consultant.
That being said, I don't believe it is necessary to do 20+ hours of live cases to pass such an interview. Even MBB only cook with water, and too much preparation can also lead to "analysis paralysis". There are definitely diminishing returns, maybe even negative returns to prepping too much.
You easily come across as a robot that memorized everything, rather than an authentic, intelligent human being. I personally always prefer a candidate who is able to think on his or her feet, can creatively tackle problems and who has the openness and backbone to admit when they don't have a clue over someone who has memorized 327 frameworks and 713 brain teasers but is about as relaxed and authentic as Cher's face these days...
To me, talent, raw intelligence, creativity, and personality beat preparation 10 times out of 10 (I mean as long as it's not evident that the candidate just is sloppy and doesn't give a f*ck). Facts and methods can be taught, those qualities can't.
(editiert)
Verwandte Produkte
McKinsey Solve Game Simulation Package von Francesco
- Spiel das Ecosystem Game (Coral Reef & Mountain Ridge)
- Spiel das Redrock Game (alle 4 Phasen enthalten)
- Erhate die Imbellus Solve Combo und den McKinsey Imbellus Game Secrets Guide GRATIS
Premium-Mitgliedschaft (1 Woche)
- ALLE Ressourcen für deine Case-Interview-Vorbereitung, die du benötigsz
- Unbeschränkte Meetings mit Gleichgesinnten
- Zugang zu über #number-of-cases# Cases, Video-Tutorials und 220+ Case-Interview-Übungen
Einstieg ins Consulting - All-in-One für Strategieberatungen von Alexandre
- Entwickelt von 2 BCG-Beratern
- Deckt die meisten Beratungsunternehmen ab
- Bringt Dich hinter die Kulissen der Beratungswelt
Einstieg in die Consultingbranche - Branchenübersichten von Alexandre
- Entwickelt von 2 BCG-Beratern
- Deckt 15+ Industrien ab
- Praktische Tipps, um jede Industrie zu knacken
Einstieg ins Consulting - Frameworks, die ich gerne gewusst hätte von Alexandre
- Entwickelt von 2 BCG-Beratern
- Deckt die häufigsten Interview-Cases ab
- Enthält praktische Tipps, um den Case zu knacken
BCG Online Case Combo: Software Simulation von Francesco
- Übe mit 6 Chatbot-Tests (Casey Style), einschließlich 4 Software-Simulationen
- Teste Dich selbst mit 4 Live One-way Video-Interviews (mit KI-generierten Tipps)
- Erhalte kostenlos den BCG Online Case Secrets Guide
BCG Online Case Secrets von Francesco
- Meistere die 5 Arten von Fragen, die der Chatbot stellt
- Entdecke die genauen Schritte zur Vorbereitung auf das 1-minütige Video-Assessment
- Erfahre wichtige Insider-Tipps von Kandidat:innen, die bestanden haben
Imbellus Solve Combo: Guide + Videos von Francesco
- Schau Dir in 23 Minuten an, wie Du das Ecosystem Spiel knackst
- Finde heraus, wie Du alle 4 Runden des Redrocks meisterst
- Erhalte den Guide McKinsey Imbellus Game Secrets kostenfrei dazu
Imbellus Test von McKinsey – Guide von Luca
- Detaillierte und vollständige Analyse des Spiels
- Beispiele zur Lösung des Spiels
- Praktische Tipps & um den Imbellus zu knacken
McKinsey Imbellus Solve Game Secrets von Francesco
- Lerne die genauen Schritte, um die 6 Spiele zu knacken
- Entdecke, wie Du die 5 getesteten Fertigkeiten beherrschen kannst
- Erfahre wichtige Insider-Tipps von Kandidat.innen, die das Spiel bestanden haben
The Secret McKinsey PEI Cheat Sheet von Robert
- Lerne, wie Du Dich richtig vorbereitest und Dein McKinsey PEI strukturierst
- Beeindrucke Deinen McKinsey-Interviewer mit einem perfekten PEI
- Spare viel Zeit bei Deiner PEI-Vorbereitung
BCG Potential Test #2 von Gaurav
- BCG Potential Test mit 23 Fragen zum "World Electrification Case"
- Erstellt von Ex-MBB-Interviewer Gaurav
- Format und Stil wie der echte BCG-Test
BCG Potential Test #1 von Francesco
- BCG Potential Test mit 23 Fragen zum "CoverCell Case"
- Von Ex-BCG-Berater Francesco erstellt
- Format und Stil wie der echte BCG-Test
Prep Guide for McKinsey PST von PrepLounge
- McKinsey PST Guide inkl. 13 Seiten voller nützlicher Tipps
- Von Ex-McKinsey-Beratern erstellt
- Ausführliche Informationen über Teststruktur, Fragetypen & Voraussetzungen
McKinsey PST #3 von Riccardo
- PST mit 26 Fragen zum "Delicious Juice Case"
- Von Ex-MBB-Berater Riccardo erstellt
- Branchen: Getränke, Tourismus, Pharma
McKinsey PST #2 von Gaurav
- PST mit 26 Fragen zum "WeKlin Case"
- Von Ex-McKinsey-Beratern erstellt
- Branchen: Einzelhandel, Energie, Franchise
McKinsey PST #1 von PrepLounge
- PST mit 26 Fragen zum "FloraFashion Case"
- Von Ex-McKinsey-Beratern erstellt
- Branchen: Einzelhandel, Energie, Franchise
Premium-Mitgliedschaft (6 Wochen)
- ALLE Ressourcen für deine Case-Interview-Vorbereitung, die du benötigst
- Unbeschränkte Meetings mit Gleichgesinnten
- Zugang zu über #number-of-cases# Cases, Video-Tutorials und 220+ Case-Interview-Übungen
Verwandte Artikel
Verwandte Cases
Verwandte Unternehmen
Verwandte Case-Interview-Basics-Artikel
7S-Framework von McKinsey
Erfahre, was genau das 7S-Framework von McKinsey ist und wie es Unternehmen dabei unterstützt, Stärken zu maximieren und Schwachstellen zu identifizieren.
Wachstumspyramide
Die McKinsey Growth Pyramid ist ein strukturiertes Framework für nachhaltige Unternehmensentwicklung. Finde heraus, wie du sie im Case-Interview nutzen kannst.
Influence Modell
Das Influence Modell von McKinsey ist ein strategisches Werkzeug, das entwickelt wurde, um Veränderungsprozesse in Organisationen zu optimieren.
McKinsey Imbellus Game
Erfahre alles über das McKinsey Imbellus Game und wie du dich damit auf ein Bewerbungsgespräch bei einem großen Consulting Unternehmen vorbereiten kannst!
Bain Sova Test
Erfahre alles rund um den Bain Sova Test und wie man diesen Test bei Bain & Company bei Job Interviews für die Eignungsprüfung der Bewerber nutzt.
Thank you for clarifying Alessandro! In that case, what exactly is expected of undergraduate (and ug non business) candidates in terms of knowledge concerning economics, business concepts, finance concepts/technical knowledge etc?
(editiert)
Don't agree. Every candidate is expected to know the basic concepts like NPV. What if the objective of the case is to calculate NPV?
Vlad, I have never seen a case given at undergraduate level that includes this concept. I also attended McKinsey workshops where they explicitly said you don't need to know NPV or DCF. Understanding it would certainly not hurt and could lead to some interesting discussions, but there won't be an undergraduate case to calculate NPV, full stop.
Vlad and Alessandro, your disagreement strikes at the core of why a lot of undergraduate candidates are confused about what is required......