BCG Dubai vs Kearney North America

I have lived in 10 countries, including Middle East (Qatar), and I know what it's like to move around. So let me provide my perspective, which is really about what kind of person you are:

If you're the kind of person that is comfortable switching between places, go for it. Dubai is a fantastic international location and opens all kinds of doors (similar to having worked in Singapore, for instance). Expat life with both families and young/single professionals is flourishing. You'll be able to save up some decent money thanks to good salaries and low taxes. Travelling in the region is very nice, too! All in all it can be a great episode in your life but very different from what you know (have you been yet?).

If you're just not that kind of person, don't like the Middle East regarding lifestyle and are generally hesitant to change, you will have a hard time! Setting yourself up for success in consulting means being able to switch off all other concerns outside of work and there's a danger you might end up miserable and burnt out before year 1 is over. In that case, Kearney in NA seems like an excellent option!

So, what kind of person are you?

Hi there,

Quite frankly you're overcomplicating this with 5 different items to consider!

Pick the two that matter. You need to boil this problem down and simplify it like you might a case. Figure out what matters and then decide along those lines.

The decision is really “Do I want to suck it up for 2-3 years and be in a place I really don't like in order to ”be set" for the rest of my life" or “Do I want to be in a country/place I enjoy so I can setup my life/future already”. It's honestly that simple!

Hey there,

In general, I would always prioritize MBB over tier-2 and others for a long-term perspective. What you put in on your end for both opportunities is the same, yet the benefits for BCG are much higher.

• BCG will offer more international opportunities while on the job and thereafter (considerations 1+2)
• Can't really comment on the 3rd consideration. My guess is that it is generally easier, the larger the firm is.
• The type of work you do in MBB is more strategic than in other firms (4). 
• Lifestyle depends on what you want. Some people love the Dubai expat life, others hate it. On the plus side, you are well-positioned to travel the world on your off days + the salary you get is tax-free (5).

Cheers,

Florian

In general I would say that work where you want to work as that is where you are most likely to excel. If you join BCG Dubai with the aim of transferring to NA, it can happen but there is so much uncertainty involved. For example, there may not be a spot at an NA office available in 2 years for your role, sponsorship could become problematic etc. etc. 

If on the other hand you want to use this role to do an MBA in the US and then join MBB I would say go with BCG for the prestige.

Best,

Udayan

Have a look at this article for tips & guidance on how to choose-https://www.preplounge.com/en/articles/how-do-i-know-which-career-is-right-for-me